Hi der
.
Theoretically, the UE team exists because the average Sythe User doesn't have common sense. How does that work? Yes, the ranks are nice, I'm not saying they should be removed. Retitled wouldn't be a bad idea, as it gives less implication that users should go to user educators for knowledge.
Generally, those are just ranks to signify that those people know something. They aren't there to ask them questions regarding the language. Most of them don't even know everything about what their rank holds.
And yes, the rank is generally used to distinguish one user from another. With the general idea that the distinguished one is going to make a brighter, more knowledgeable post than the other.
This is not the case with User Educators, as the information they know is a dab of butter on a whole loaf of bread. My thought has been, and always will be, that the point of the User Education section is to learn something. The rank of User Educator is pointless, as, in general, a majority of the User Educator's don't know shit about the topic they're discussing.
Targeted User Educator Ranks would be more suitable, and then require your educators to show immense knowledge in their field of study. Then it'd make sense. Right now... you've got 30 teachers... who know what? How to change a light bulb with an ipod?
They're rather different. You can have intelligence without having much knowledge. Theoretically, the ability to speak is seen as intelligent. Knowledge is different as it requires intelligence to gain knowledge.
I don't dislike UE =/. I dislike the people who assume they're worthy of teaching others stuff they know little about.
Well that was an interesting read, not sure where to begin.
I guess first off, the ranks mean nothing. If people see it as trust, that is their own fault. Anyone with even a bit of common sense can see that. Don't get me wrong the ranks are nice, and they are an incentive, but they are NOT necessary in the slightest, and as you well know Deacon, they weren't originally even there. When I first started writing my guides it was a User Title and that's all.
Theoretically, the UE team exists because the average Sythe User doesn't have common sense. How does that work? Yes, the ranks are nice, I'm not saying they should be removed. Retitled wouldn't be a bad idea, as it gives less implication that users should go to user educators for knowledge.
You seem to be debating the word choice in the term "User Educator" more than anything. Did you have a suggestion for a replacement term? The reason we have it is the same reason we have VB programmer, Scar, etc. ranks. They're just there for people actually active in the section.
Generally, those are just ranks to signify that those people know something. They aren't there to ask them questions regarding the language. Most of them don't even know everything about what their rank holds.
And yes, the rank is generally used to distinguish one user from another. With the general idea that the distinguished one is going to make a brighter, more knowledgeable post than the other.
This is not the case with User Educators, as the information they know is a dab of butter on a whole loaf of bread. My thought has been, and always will be, that the point of the User Education section is to learn something. The rank of User Educator is pointless, as, in general, a majority of the User Educator's don't know shit about the topic they're discussing.
Targeted User Educator Ranks would be more suitable, and then require your educators to show immense knowledge in their field of study. Then it'd make sense. Right now... you've got 30 teachers... who know what? How to change a light bulb with an ipod?
I respect everything you've said Deacon and for the most part (if not all of it) is correct, however you seem to be looking at it in a different light.
If I recall correctly there was a comment on the difference between "knowledge" and "intelligence" which I'm here to tell you are essentially the same thing.
They're rather different. You can have intelligence without having much knowledge. Theoretically, the ability to speak is seen as intelligent. Knowledge is different as it requires intelligence to gain knowledge.
Well I'm not entirely sure what else I can do to refute your statements, so if you have a comment back Deacon, I'd be more than willing to converse with you about it. I know that you dislike to UE and how it is run so if you have a suitable alternative, then I'm all ears. (To clarify, removing it is not a suitable alternative).
I don't dislike UE =/. I dislike the people who assume they're worthy of teaching others stuff they know little about.







