• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

The Existence of God

  • Thread starter Thread starter Skilling not Killing
  • Start date Start date

Does God Exist?

  • Yes

    Votes: 990 57.3%
  • No

    Votes: 739 42.7%

  • Total voters
    1,729
Status
Not open for further replies.
1) Like all stars, the sun generates its energy by a nuclear process known as thermonuclear fusion. Every second that passes, the sun compresses 564 million tons of hydrogen into 560 million tons of helium with 4 million tons of matter released as energy. After all that the sun has only used up 2% of the hydrogen it had the day it came into existence. The sun is not a process used only to the sun. Every star in the sky generates its energy in the same way. Throughout the cosmos there are 25 quintillion stars, each converting hydrogen into helium, which reduces the total amount of hydrogen in the cosmos. If everywhere in the cosmos hydrogen is being consumed and if the process has been going on forever, how much hydrogen should be left?

Example: Let's say I drive my car without putting any more gas into it. As I drive and drive, what is eventually going to happen? I am going to run out of gas. If the cosmos have been here forever, we would have run out of hydrogen a long time ago. The fact is that the sun still has 98% of its original hydrogen. The fact is that hydrogen is the most abundant material in the universe. Everywhere we look in space we can see the hydrogen 21-cm line in the spectrum a piece of light only given off by hydrogen. This could not be unless we had a beginning.

Giving credit to www.doesgodexist.org, which gave me this information on the sun and stars.


Firstly, a site like www.doesgodexist.org is most likely very biased and give information that proves their cause.
Also saying that because there is hydrogen which leads to formation of suns doesn't prove that there wasn't matter before the big bang. There could have been matter with completely different compositions that aren't even close to what matter is today.

2) I have researched a bit, but I'm not getting really into and researching it a lot because I have better things to do. Anyways, you don't know if I have researched it correctly or not, and Biogenesis is most likely true, but is completely illogical when you say the most BASIC lifeforms ended up creating complex lifeforms that grew up to learn how to think, talk, wright, make computers, and other things. It's just not possible.

How is it illogical for us to simply grow brains to do all of that? Through millions of years mutations occur that benefit us and those stay. Through all this evolution we come into what we are today, a very complex organism that was built through millions of years. With a big and complex enough brain all those things you said are possible.

Can you provide some proof as to how it is illogical? You just state it. Also if it weren't that, since we clearly exist what is the proof of your belief of how it happened.

You claim that you were an Atheist and now reject the mainstream Atheist beliefs. I'd like to read some of that evidence that you have seen that completely changed your mind.
 
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Actually, I have been looking into them because I have found that they go the other way around by proving that there was once no matter, and how the sun and the stars would not give off hydrogen anymore if the universe was eternal. So don't talk about Chemistry like you know it all when in reality you're just saying I know nothing about it so you can say my claims are false without giving an explanation on how they're false.

So, I see you know a lot about Astrophysics and Chemistry, I assume you have an explanation to how my claims are bullshit. Please explain.
So you're saying you've studied your arguments in depth and yet you rip them from a site biased towards Christianity?
 
1) Like all stars, the sun generates its energy by a nuclear process known as thermonuclear fusion. Every second that passes, the sun compresses 564 million tons of hydrogen into 560 million tons of helium with 4 million tons of matter released as energy. After all that the sun has only used up 2% of the hydrogen it had the day it came into existence. The sun is not a process used only to the sun. Every star in the sky generates its energy in the same way. Throughout the cosmos there are 25 quintillion stars, each converting hydrogen into helium, which reduces the total amount of hydrogen in the cosmos. If everywhere in the cosmos hydrogen is being consumed and if the process has been going on forever, how much hydrogen should be left?

Entropy is likely reset in a "big crunch" at the end of a universe's "lifespan".

xx mdv xx said:
Example: Let's say I drive my car without putting any more gas into it. As I drive and drive, what is eventually going to happen? I am going to run out of gas. If the cosmos have been here forever, we would have run out of hydrogen a long time ago. The fact is that the sun still has 98% of its original hydrogen. The fact is that hydrogen is the most abundant material in the universe. Everywhere we look in space we can see the hydrogen 21-cm line in the spectrum a piece of light only given off by hydrogen. This could not be unless we had a beginning.

Correct, the fusion process has not been going on forever. It began a finite amount of time ago.

Giving credit to www.doesgodexist.org, which gave me this information on the sun and stars.

xx mdv xx said:
2) I have researched a bit, but I'm not getting really into and researching it a lot because I have better things to do. Anyways, you don't know if I have researched it correctly or not, and Biogenesis is most likely true, but is completely illogical when you say the most BASIC lifeforms ended up creating complex lifeforms that grew up to learn how to think, talk, wright, make computers, and other things. It's just not possible.

Why isn't it possible? Have you actively researched this in depth for many years? Have you discussed your ideas with the leading minds of today?

xx mdv xx said:
3) I may be wrong, but I think it is fact that time is the measure of changes in matter, and if time is finite, there can't be an infinite amount of time because time is finite. Matter and time are finite, not infinite. Meaning they can't be put in a universe that has always existed, that's impossible. I've been told that was fact and I thought Steven Hawking proved it. Also, what I said about the sun proves that the universe could not have existed for eternity or else we would run out of Hydrogen.

Time itself began in the Big Bang. One cannot speak of "before" the Big Bang since there was no "before". Why the Big Bang occurred, I don't know, but let's keep an open mind until evidence comes up showing what might have done it.

Shredderbeam just made me an athiest.

Excellent.

Actually, I have been looking into them because I have found that they go the other way around by proving that there was once no matter, and how the sun and the stars would not give off hydrogen anymore if the universe was eternal. So don't talk about Chemistry like you know it all when in reality you're just saying I know nothing about it so you can say my claims are false without giving an explanation on how they're false.

The matter in the universe could have existed "forever", outside of time, but it wouldn't have been undergoing fusion.
 
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
One may say the same thing towards you, you should keep an open mind until there is evidence of a God.
He is keeping an open mind. I am keeping an open mind. The thing is, there is no evidence in support of the existence of a God therefore I highly doubt the existence of one.

If anyone can provide irrefutable proof of God, sure, I'll admit his existence.

On that topic, Darren, you still paying anyone that $1,000 for proof of God? Or did you raise the stakes?
 
One may say the same thing towards you, you should keep an open mind until there is evidence of a God.

That's exactly what I'm doing, and advising everybody else to do.

He is keeping an open mind. I am keeping an open mind. The thing is, there is no evidence in support of the existence of a God therefore I highly doubt the existence of one.

If anyone can provide irrefutable proof of God, sure, I'll admit his existence.

On that topic, Darren, you still paying anyone that $1,000 for proof of God? Or did you raise the stakes?

I raised it to $10,000.
 
I have a question though, I've been told by many people and have also heard that time is finite, making matter finite, so therefore there can't be an infinite amount of matter because there is only a finite amount of time and the science definition of time is the change in matter. Is that fact or theory? Many people have been telling me it's fact but the way you guys are trying to get your point across to me is that that is just a theory.
 
I have a question though, I've been told by many people and have also heard that time is finite, making matter finite, so therefore there can't be an infinite amount of matter because there is only a finite amount of time and the science definition of time is the change in matter. Is that fact or theory? Many people have been telling me it's fact but the way you guys are trying to get your point across to me is that that is just a theory.

Time being finite does not automatically mean that matter did not exist at some point. The singularity that later formed our universe could have existed in a timeless state "prior" to the Big Bang.
 
Remember In the Bible it Says man's brain will always look for a reason when sometimes their is no reason or proof but its real, I mean what do you want God to do come down here sit beside you and play Runescape , I mean Seriously everyone is trying to find stuff and find evidence that he is real the human brain is always looking for answers, But time will show The End.
I am a Christian and yes I do Believe in God-Respect
 
Remember Charles Darwin, on his death bed he said "It was only a theory" remember yes animals do evolve into their surrounding habitat, and remember where did we come from it takes 2 people to make 1 or others,
WHich we didnt come from a spec of dust or any such thing Just remember 2=x and without 2 = none so their has to be someone such as God, Which the human brain cannot nearly understand what it is but is always trying to look for a answer.
God-Bless
 
Remember In the Bible it Says man's brain will always look for a reason when sometimes their is no reason or proof but its real, I mean what do you want God to do come down here sit beside you and play Runescape , I mean Seriously everyone is trying to find stuff and find evidence that he is real the human brain is always looking for answers, But time will show The End.
I am a Christian and yes I do Believe in God-Respect

How do you know that God exists? What leads you to believe?

Remember Charles Darwin, on his death bed he said "It was only a theory" remember yes animals do evolve into their surrounding habitat, and remember where did we come from it takes 2 people to make 1 or others,
WHich we didnt come from a spec of dust or any such thing Just remember 2=x and without 2 = none so their has to be someone such as God, Which the human brain cannot nearly understand what it is but is always trying to look for a answer.
God-Bless

Darwin said nothing of the sort on his death-bed - but even if he did, it would be irrelevant. Would the Pope renouncing the Bible make you an atheist?

Generally, to make another human, a pair of humans have to come together, but this wasn't always the way. The very first life forms reproduced by fission (and a great many still do today).
 
Darwin said nothing of the sort on his death-bed - but even if he did, it would be irrelevant. Would the Pope renouncing the Bible make you an atheist?

Generally, to make another human, a pair of humans have to come together, but this wasn't always the way. The very first life forms reproduced by fission (and a great many still do today).


1st, The rumor was that he said that he was wrong. This was just a rumor and is untrue. It is truth thought that it is just a "Theory".

2nd, Tell me what living organisms have been made recently that have a reproductive system.
 
1st, The rumor was that he said that he was wrong. This was just a rumor and is untrue. It is truth thought that it is just a "Theory".

It is true that evolution is a theory, but it cannot be said that it is "just" a theory. A theory in science is a very serious matter, requiring large amounts of supporting evidence, multiple predictions that have come true, and neat integration with all other scientific theories/laws. It is far more than a hypothesis.

This might help: http://wilstar.com/theories.htm

hashslinger said:
2nd, Tell me what living organisms have been made recently that have a reproductive system.

None. It is a very difficult feat to create life in a laboratory, much less life with reproductive systems.
 
It is true that evolution is a theory, but it cannot be said that it is "just" a theory. A theory in science is a very serious matter, requiring large amounts of supporting evidence, multiple predictions that have come true, and neat integration with all other scientific theories/laws. It is far more than a hypothesis.

This might help: http://wilstar.com/theories.htm
Yes, I understand that. How do yo know that an intelligent creator didnt make the earth the way evolutionists think it was made? There is nothing that says he couldnt make it.

None. It is a very difficult feat to create life in a laboratory, much less life with reproductive systems.

then why did you say: The very first life forms reproduced by fission (and a great many still do today).
 
Yes, I understand that. How do yo know that an intelligent creator didnt make the earth the way evolutionists think it was made? There is nothing that says he couldnt make it.

The evidence that is available suggests that natural forces shaped the Earth. It is possible that an intelligent creator shaped it, but there is no evidence to demonstrate that one did.

hashslinger said:
then why did you say: The very first life forms reproduced by fission (and a great many still do today).

The very first life forms were some sort of basic cell that reproduced by splitting itself in two. Today, many bacteria still do this.
 
Shredderbeam think of it this way, Imagine a ship with food in it, going back and forth to a country and loading food and coming back with more with no one guiding the ship.

Would you believe it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top