A TWC seems silly. However I would support something along the lines of a user title that refers back to someone's pardon if they have recently pardoned. Question is, how long would it stay? You do know that by this suggestion you're making your own grave ready?Zzzzz. Just another day someone scams after getting pardoned and the community is all like "I could've predicted that!". Please become a fortune-teller.
Oh and his DNT removal was voted 9/0.
This and even though I believed @Mercedes was a sketchy person all the time he's been on Sythe we can't hold them accountable for something that hasn't happened yet. It seems silly to vote No on DNT removals or pardons just because we believe an user should not be trusted. There's only so much we can do as staff and that is punish him for the things he has done, but also allowing them a way back if they meet a certain amount of requirements; which he did. I'm not feeling bad at all for allowing him back to the community at all. He screwed things up, we didn't. Hopefully he regrets his decisions sincerely once, because he'll never learn to do business and deal with money properly this way.If a pardon is suppose to be a clean slate, why would they receive a TWC? The whole point of taking away the conditional pardoning (user gets TWC if pardon is accepted, placed in last chance usergroup, etc.) is so that pardoning users aren't treated with negativity and are accepted for what you've done, and it's over with. If they think you're a threat, you shouldn't be pardoned.
I know this isn't quite in context and I love you but isn't that exactly staff's job, to not vote yes on pardons if they don't feel the person can be trusted to rejoin the community and not scam? A while ago staff weren't pressured to accept every pardon in site by Richard's bullshit to get every single member he can on his dying site so a lot fewer pardons were accepted because it was only people who deserved it and who likely wouldn't scam. Clearly things aren't working out now because a lot of pardoned users end up banned again, most of them for scamming (just looking at this year's list: Hello Its Me, Coolperson3, xSeventeen17, Enemee, Oldbeast1994 for like the 5th time???, Dbl Frostbite, Folt who got pardoned AGAIN?, Deniese-Ricardo, QBDyce who also got pardoned again, Skeptic, Lastofuspt2, and now Mercedes and Ext Bail who were both banned in the same day.) Obviously not all of these were preventable, but i'm sure some of them could have been prevented had staff actually taken into account whether or not they believed the individual would scam again. Oldbeast had scammed like 5 times, Folt is a serial scammer/sniper, Deniese-Ricardo impersonated an admin to scam pocket change and Mercedes was literally sketchy from the second of his arrival on Sythe.... I'm not saying to deny every pardon because "the person might scam again", but staff should definitely be discussing this when the pardon goes to the staff lounge as to whether or not they believe the person should be rejoining the community...?It seems silly to vote No on DNT removals or pardons just because we believe an user should not be trusted.
remove donor status, remove vouches, archive their old threads, everything. Allow them to come back, sure, but make them start from 0. They shouldn't be handed back an account that's perfect to scam unsuspecting members (let's be honest - $666 donor & 150+ vouches allowed Mercedes to make people go first and capitalise on his scam quit.
Wasn't going to chip in on this as I wouldn't mind either scenario, but having read @HNCdice's suggestion it sparked some interest. However, I personally think it'd be a good idea to take this further. The only reason people would pardon rather than just save time and ban evade (I believe) is to get back to smooth trading with an account which has built up a certain image on the site. If you strip these people of EVERYTHING, they'd truly need to start again and, even if people are going to re-offend (which, unfortunately, is inevitable in some cases i.e. Mercedes) then it'll slow this process down and possibly reduce the magnitude - remove donor status, remove vouches, archive their old threads, everything. Allow them to come back, sure, but make them start from 0. They shouldn't be handed back an account that's perfect to scam unsuspecting members (let's be honest - $666 donor & 150+ vouches allowed Mercedes to make people go first and capitalise on his scam quit. To be perfectly honest it's a relief he didn't take way more) and I believe my idea, albeit drastic, could prevent this.
I know this isn't quite in context and I love you but isn't that exactly staff's job, to not vote yes on pardons if they don't feel the person can be trusted to rejoin the community and not scam?
Pretty much 100% my thoughts. Agree with your sentiments. Unfortunately there is no perfect solution, but all we can do is hope for the best.
Suggestions I have seen so far, some I like more than others
I think the last one would help, obviously it wouldnt be a complete solution but I think that its a start. What do you think @Yousuckv2
- Wiping vouches
- Giving TWC
- Make them start a new account
- Remove their donor status
I'd have to disagree with you. Putting this situation aside; we have had PLENTY of people pardon and never reoffend the rules. It's definitely a hard judgement call on whether to allow someone back into the community after scamming, but, we are online. There are plenty on conartists out there looking to make a quick couple bucks and would dedicate time into pretending to prove that they're a changed character. As a member, I look through a majority of pardons and jot down a mental note of how I feel about the pardon and situation, and you know, a lot of the times I agree with pardoning a user that the staff has agreed on.Just looked into what happened. What an embarrassment for the Sythe staff. I can see why you are so defensive. But in all Honesty it is the staff's fault who collectively decided to pardon a scammer. When it comes to things like pardons, people have to be able to make decisive judgement calls on a person's character, and you cant afford to let the wrong guy back in because you KNOW that if he is insincere, he WILL use his old vouches and reputation to scam JUST LIKE HE DID PREVIOUSLY.
Your suggestion has a lot of depth and could definitely be a good consideration.How about having your vouches wiped after a pardon for scamming. Wouldn't be hard for staff to archive the threads and makes it so people couldn't rely on previous trust (which they broke when they scammed.) This may not prevent them from scamming again but will 100% not allow them to walk away with hundreds of dollars.
Considering vouches are the main staple of trade on this site, its a huge set back however still allows you to rebuild your reputation. People are less likely to scam if they know there is more than just a pardon between them and returning.
I have been pardoned 3 or 4 times (hacked sythe account used to scam, evasion, paypal limit during a trade, owing money to Matt) myself, don't consider myself a threat to anyone. But its a case by case basis.