• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

An extra feature regarding Report A Scammer section

Status
Not open for further replies.

Slash

Formerly known as Slashz

Slash Donor
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Sythe Gold
51,367
Messages
52,723
Vouch Thread
Click Here
Discord Unique ID
372815675691106304
Discord Username
faaizy
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
There should be an option to allow specific users to be able to comment on threads made in the RAS section (the person you're reporting, mainly)

This will save the need of mods jumping to conclusions and banning a member, only to find out the actual story a few days later when the member posts a dispute, and then end up unbanning them. It just wastes everyone's time.

I've seen this happen too many times, and in most of the situations the mod did not even bother to contact the reported user about his side of the story.

I don't really know how hard it would be to do this, but if there could be an alternative fix to these type of situations, that would be awesome.
 
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Wubba Lubba Dub Dub
The Mortyest Morty
Discord Verified
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Le Kingdoms Player
Two Factor Authentication User
Spam Forum Participant
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Signature of the Month Winner
Users can already submit replies in RASC that staff can just merge to the report
 
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Users can already submit replies in RASC that staff can just merge to the report

That isn't really obvious to newcomers, it would be way more convenient if you could just reply on the same topic.

Plus you guys would probably ban before you were to see those replies (based off what i've seen)
 
That isn't really obvious to newcomers, it would be way more convenient if you could just reply on the same topic.

Plus you guys would probably ban before you were to see those replies (based off what i've seen)

If somebody is banned, that's for a reason.
If there was no reason for a ban, they would not be banned.

If somebody wants to pitch in on a scamreport against them, they should handle the situation with the scammed person.
 
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
If somebody is banned, that's for a reason.
If there was no reason for a ban, they would not be banned.

And what if the reason is wrong? but the mods only realize it later after a dispute is made? The dispute could've just been saved if the mods waited and heard a reply from the accused member, but of course that would only be possible if you you could actually reply on scam reports made against yourself


If somebody wants to pitch in on a scamreport against them, they should handle the situation with the scammed person.

You just said you should handle a situation with yourself
A scam report against a person, is the person who got scammed

Obviously you meant handle the situation with the person posting the scam report, but in that case that wouldn't be a very fair thing to do at all.
In the case where the reported person didn't agree with the persons reply at all, he wouldn't really add to the thread and the mods would never hear of his reply, when in reality he could've been telling the truth
 
Poképedia
Tier 1 Prizebox
Live Streamer
Pokémon Trainer
The Dark Side
Oktoberfest 2013
MushyMuncher
Rupee
St. Patrick's Day 2013
Poker Chip
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
Ninja
Tortoise Penis
DIAF
St. Patrick's Day 2014
Cool Kid
Cook
Heidy
Halloween 2013
Village Drunk
Voluntaryist
We Are Legion
Penguin
The problem with this is that users don't know they've been reported. Reported posts go into a hidden section for staff to handle, and aren't visible to everyone until they've been handled and merged into the archive.
 
And what if the reason is wrong? but the mods only realize it later after a dispute is made? The dispute could've just been saved if the mods waited and heard a reply from the accused member, but of course that would only be possible if you you could actually reply on scam reports made against yourself
What could be wrong about evidence? That's what I don't get.
If let's say somebody is scammed for a GP sale, and the victim reports the scammer.
If the screenshots are valid and correct, we ban the scammer.

If it's an account sale, and the report is not clear, or the situation is unclear, it is cleared up by PMing the 'scammer' and giving them 24 hours.

Neither situation would benefit from the update you propose.

You just said you should handle a situation with yourself
A scam report against a person, is the person who got scammed

Obviously you meant handle the situation with the person posting the scam report, but in that case that wouldn't be a very fair thing to do at all.
In the case where the reported person didn't agree with the persons reply at all, he wouldn't really add to the thread and the mods would never hear of his reply, when in reality he could've been telling the truth

If the 'scammer' wants to reply to the 'victim', why would that need to be on the scamreport per se?
That's my whole point.
If the 'scammer' wants to resolve or clear up the situation I don't see why a PM or a skype message wouldn't suffice.
 
Users can already submit replies in RASC that staff can just merge to the report

This. You're suggesting admins give higher usergroup permission to accusers which is inefficient, as that permission would have to be removed after the case is resolved. Automation of this sounds pretty complicated to code.
 
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
What could be wrong about evidence? That's what I don't get.
If let's say somebody is scammed for a GP sale, and the victim reports the scammer.
If the screenshots are valid and correct, we ban the scammer.

If it's an account sale, and the report is not clear, or the situation is unclear, it is cleared up by PMing the 'scammer' and giving them 24 hours.

Neither situation would benefit from the update you propose.

Sometimes the mods ASSUME the screenshots are valid enough, and after a dispute is made they realize they were wrong.

EXAMPLE #1
Ban:
http://www.sythe.org/report-scammer-archive/1802218-reporting-user-burntish.html

Dispute:
http://www.sythe.org/dispute-forum-archive/1802454-disputing-ban-behalf-burntish.html

He was unbanned, this isn't the first time this happened to him btw
Sellinanbuyinrsngold, same thing happened
I'm basically referring to every single ban dispute that was approved after that user was banned.
Those threads would be pointless if you could just clear up things right there and then

Of course it would benefit, the disputes wouldnt be necessary as everything would be handled on the thread


If the 'scammer' wants to reply to the 'victim', why would that need to be on the scamreport per se?
That's my whole point.
If the 'scammer' wants to resolve or clear up the situation I don't see why a PM or a skype message wouldn't suffice.

Why would someone who scammed you want to resolve a situation if it was in their intentions to scam in the first place? They'd obviously try to fuck each other over, and one of them would be bsing
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2014
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
I have been through this 2 or maybe 3 times now where I am accused and then banned without anyone even letting me know or asking me what happened. I would suggest a system where the people involved in a scam report get a pm so they are notified of it. And also they should then have a time period to tell their side of the story on the thread like slash has pointed out.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Then anyone can reply to any report and it becomes a normal section and is more hassle to moderate than the current system of just merging responses.
 
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Then anyone can reply to any report and it becomes a normal section and is more hassle to moderate than the current system of just merging responses.

"There should be an option to allow specific users to be able to comment on threads made in the RAS section (the person you're reporting, mainly)"
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Users are distinguishable by usergroup for that kind of thing, so it's impossible to implement without developing a whole new mod tool (where mods would have to input usernames allowed to reply). Which is a huge solution for a small problem.
 
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Users are distinguishable by usergroup for that kind of thing, so it's impossible to implement without developing a whole new mod tool (where mods would have to input usernames allowed to reply). Which is a huge solution for a small problem.

Ah okay, any alternatives you think that could solve this?

If not, I guess we'll have to work with what we got (jack goff's post)
 
Users are distinguishable by usergroup for that kind of thing, so it's impossible to implement without developing a whole new mod tool (where mods would have to input usernames allowed to reply). Which is a huge solution for a small problem.

Would it be efficient to create a new usergroup which you can place accused users into, maybe called "Pending Scam Report" or something similar? That way without being banned they can be restricted in the market from trading, and would have the "privileges" to reply in the RaS section.

Powerbot does something similar, where they put users in a "Restricted" group which doesn't allow the users to access the Market sections of the forum, but allows them to respond to scamming threads.
 
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Would it be efficient to create a new usergroup which you can place accused users into, maybe called "Pending Scam Report" or something similar? That way without being banned they can be restricted in the market from trading, and would have the "privileges" to reply in the RaS section.

Powerbot does something similar, where they put users in a "Restricted" group which doesn't allow the users to access the Market sections of the forum, but allows them to respond to scamming threads.

Users are distinguishable by usergroup for that kind of thing, so it's impossible to implement without developing a whole new mod tool (where mods would have to input usernames allowed to reply). Which is a huge solution for a small problem.

Not gonna work :l
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Would it be efficient to create a new usergroup which you can place accused users into, maybe called "Pending Scam Report" or something similar? That way without being banned they can be restricted in the market from trading, and would have the "privileges" to reply in the RaS section.

Powerbot does something similar, where they put users in a "Restricted" group which doesn't allow the users to access the Market sections of the forum, but allows them to respond to scamming threads.

In the time that you add them to this usergroup via an Admin, you could check the report and contact the accused for a response if one is needed.

That's why it's most efficient to ban if you feel there is enough concrete evidence and let them dispute if they think they are wronged or to ask them for their side of the story/input if there isn't concrete evidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top