• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Prove my existence within a state

DIAF
Gohan has AIDS
Lawrence
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
:D

Reality is the paradox of existence. We obviously can't definitively prove reality, but what is the point of trying to do so? Perceiving it is good enough. I think therefore I am. Thoughts are intangible ideas that can only be created by yourself. Ideas can't be held alone. Something must be supporting that idea, the brain. The brain, a container of our thoughts. If ideas exist, the supportive block for it must exist as well. Our brain is tangible, making it's existence reality.

Exactly. In this thread, it wouldn't matter if you were proving someone's existence within a state or proving someone's existence within a McDonald's double cheeseburger. The self and reality existing is unrelated to the actual argument at hand.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
I'll take a shot at this argument. I'll start with the above quote since it seems to be the core.



I might need a little bit of clarification on what you mean by "Exists". You say literal and legal, not metaphysical, but immediately before that, it seems you question whether "reality", "you", and "I" exist. In response to that, I would say that the burden of proof that reality does not exist lies with the person making the claim that it does not. Every single argument for debate in this entire forum could be trumped with requiring the burden of proof that something as abstract as "Reality" exists before addressing the main issue.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Performative_contradiction

Essentially: The fact of having a debate or argument assumes that: 1) there is something to argue about (a reality independent of the mind exists) and 2) that there is someone to argue with (that you are not the only thinking being in the universe.)

In otherwords once you start debating you have already assumed and accepted the primacy of existence. http://www.importanceofphilosophy.com/Metaphysics_RealityIsAbsolute.html

Now that's sorted, what's the argument regarding existence within a state?
 
DIAF
Gohan has AIDS
Lawrence
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Now that's sorted, what's the argument regarding existence within a state?

Alright, I'll try to approach this objectively (any bias I may have isn't obvious to me, point it out if I do).

Let's begin with the obvious. OP needs to define a state, as he poses the question it isn't our job to set the parameters. It's impossible to debate otherwise.

Anyways, from what I've read of the very long thread, it seems there's already been a distinction made between the "State" and the "Government", mostly identifying Government as the people with the guns who coerce people into paying taxes, following laws, etc. The "State" seems to still be undefined, which seems to be a roadblock to the debate.

One thing that I do want to ask someone in your unique position as site owner, based on your previous responses on this thread, what do you consider Sythe.org to be in relation to your vision of a State? Sythe.org is run by a "Government" of sorts, which are the staff members who enforce the rules. Users pay "Taxes" involuntarily through generating advertising revenue. These are two features that a lot of people seem to attribute to the concept of the State.

The easy rebuttal that distinguishes the concept of the State from Sythe.org is that every user on Sythe.org has to voluntarily agree to join (contracts were mentioned ad nauseam earlier), whereas people are born, without their consent, to be under control of the State, and must follow the rules&practices of said State under duress.

With the exception of the consent of the person who may or may not exist in the State, and the person who uses Sythe.org, there are similarities between what most people seem to consider the concept of the State and the structure of Sythe.org. From your previous posts, it doesn't seem you have high regard for the State. I would ask if you could design your own sandbox reality without the State, what would it look like? - but in a sense, Sythe.org is that sandbox reality, and, at face value, bares similarities to the State.

I'm still working towards defining the "State", I don't know if you plan to dismiss everything I said above because the State is still not defined and I certainly haven't proven your existence in it, but responses to the above will narrow it.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Now that's sorted, what's the argument regarding existence within a state?

Alright, I'll try to approach this objectively (any bias I may have isn't obvious to me, point it out if I do).

Let's begin with the obvious. OP needs to define a state, as he poses the question it isn't our job to set the parameters. It's impossible to debate otherwise.

I am not the one claiming that you must do X because 'you exist within a state.' This is a claim of statists. It is their burden of proof firstly to define what a state is and then to prove that I exist within one.


Anyways, from what I've read of the very long thread, it seems there's already been a distinction made between the "State" and the "Government", mostly identifying Government as the people with the guns who coerce people into paying taxes, following laws, etc. The "State" seems to still be undefined, which seems to be a roadblock to the debate.

One thing that I do want to ask someone in your unique position as site owner, based on your previous responses on this thread, what do you consider Sythe.org to be in relation to your vision of a State? Sythe.org is run by a "Government" of sorts, which are the staff members who enforce the rules. Users pay "Taxes" involuntarily through generating advertising revenue. These are two features that a lot of people seem to attribute to the concept of the State.

Sythe.org is a private club run and maintained by a private firm. All users browse here on a voluntary basis. All staff members attend to their duty on a voluntary basis.

Again, I am not defining 'state' because it is not my claim that one exists or that anyone exists within one. That is the claim of statists.

If I made the claim that you exist within sythe.org therefore you have to pay me money or I'll take your house, how would you react? Do you think now that sythe.org is a state within the context of the question?

The easy rebuttal that distinguishes the concept of the State from Sythe.org is that every user on Sythe.org has to voluntarily agree to join (contracts were mentioned ad nauseam earlier), whereas people are born, without their consent, to be under control of the State, and must follow the rules&practices of said State under duress.

With the exception of the consent of the person who may or may not exist in the State, and the person who uses Sythe.org, there are similarities between what most people seem to consider the concept of the State and the structure of Sythe.org. From your previous posts, it doesn't seem you have high regard for the State. I would ask if you could design your own sandbox reality without the State, what would it look like? - but in a sense, Sythe.org is that sandbox reality, and, at face value, bares similarities to the State.

I'm still working towards defining the "State", I don't know if you plan to dismiss everything I said above because the State is still not defined and I certainly haven't proven your existence in it, but responses to the above will narrow it.

This is all noodling and off topic. The context of the question is quite simple.

Some person Alice does some act X. For the sake of argument let's say X is the act of obtaining some pot.

Men with guns in blue costumes object strongly to Alice's doing of X.

The men with guns claim to be doing business as 'the state.'

They kidnap and haul Alice before a man in a wig who calls himself a 'judge.'

According to this 'judge' the men in blue costumes with guns must release Alice unless they can prove three things, in which case they can put Alice in chains and force her to do labour at the point of a gun for many years.

The three things they must prove:
  1. Alice possessed a plant called marijuana
  2. Alice knew that she possessed said plant
  3. Alice was present within the State

Do you see that so far all of this nonsense is nothing more than people with guns hauling people before other people. Now they have this arbitrary standard which determines if Alice is released from her unjust imprisonment or if Alice becomes essentially a life-slave of these people.

The third point is impossible to make out. I have yet to see a valid argument proving that a) a state can actually be said to exist outside people's mere opinions that it does (much like god), or b) that another human being exists within this thing called a state.

Frankly all I've ever had is rubbish arguments from people who can't seem to reason their way to square one (existence exists, you are independent of my consciousness), so unless you have something good I'm not going to waste my time.
 
So we have clarified that men with guns object to Alice. Let's say you are Alice. Men with guns hauls Sythe off to the 'judge' because they disapprove of Sythe's doing of X.

Logic for men with guns actions can be explained as this. They disapprove of Sythe's doing of X; Sythe's doing of X has come within their range and grasped their attention. therefore Sythe's doing of X influences them and others within Sythe's range.

You existed within men's state because your sphere of influence reached them. Likewise theirs reached yours. So you existed in each other's states. Neither of you existed within the judge's state because the judge was unaware of either of you actions and had to be notified by men with guns. At this time, you now exist within all three persons' states and must be judged on your doing of X because by being within others' states and doing X, you have done wrong.

You always exist in your state. You exist in other's states when you bring yourself there(hence being noticed by others). You can also exist in others' states if you brought there by others.



So basically, if I wanted you to exist in a state other than your own, all I have to do it be within your sphere of influence. If I wanted you to be in anyone else's state (say a judge) all I would have to do it bring your existence to attention.

If you exist, you are in a state, unless you avoid influencing anyone. By asking us to prove you exist in a state, we can assume you both exist and are influencing us. Now, you have brought yourself into others' states.

672.png
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
So we have clarified that men with guns object to Alice. Let's say you are Alice. Men with guns hauls Sythe off to the 'judge' because they disapprove of Sythe's doing of X.

Logic for men with guns actions can be explained as this. They disapprove of Sythe's doing of X; Sythe's doing of X has come within their range and grasped their attention. therefore Sythe's doing of X influences them and others within Sythe's range.

You existed within men's state because your sphere of influence reached them. Likewise theirs reached yours. So you existed in each other's states. Neither of you existed within the judge's state because the judge was unaware of either of you actions and had to be notified by men with guns. At this time, you now exist within all three persons' states and must be judged on your doing of X because by being within others' states and doing X, you have done wrong.

You always exist in your state. You exist in other's states when you bring yourself there(hence being noticed by others). You can also exist in others' states if you brought there by others.



So basically, if I wanted you to exist in a state other than your own, all I have to do it be within your sphere of influence. If I wanted you to be in anyone else's state (say a judge) all I would have to do it bring your existence to attention.

If you exist, you are in a state, unless you avoid influencing anyone. By asking us to prove you exist in a state, we can assume you both exist and are influencing us. Now, you have brought yourself into others' states.

Same crap argument as has been posted a dozen times. I don't exist within anyone's mind anymore than I exist within a piece of paper or an abstract concept. You might have a representation of me stored in your mind, but like a photograph of me, that is not my existence. I am not present within a state even in this absurd definition of a state.
 
It's not possible to prove your existence within a state or anywhere else for that matter. You as yourself are not even able to prove that you exist within a state or anywhere else. To even come close to setting up proof that you exist you would have to have some axioms. Axioms allow you to do something in a semi consistent manner. But if there was no consistency in the first place then there would be zero need for proof of your existence or my own. Inconsistency would mean that nothing was predicable and that axioms don't even exist to begin with. We don't even truly have a definition of what existence really is. It all is about how one perceives things. So Sythe the question for you is are you able to prove we exist or that you even exist within a state. Because eventually all arguments or counter arguments would collapse on themselves.
 
Discord Verified
Cryptocurrency Discussion Participant
Paper Trading Competition Participant
If Sythe doesn't provide a definition for state, we are not acting unfairly by providing our own (check follow up below). I define a state as anything and everything as well as everywhere. Therefor sythe must exist somewhere within everything and everywhere. The only place out of this would be void, which is an impossible place for anything to exist in, therefor sythe cannot be there.

Follow up: my definition of state is based on the fact that just as a human is in a state of conciousness, a star millions of light years away is in a state of energy or a atom is in a state of movement or a planet is in a state of rotation. Everything in the universe is in a state of something. A state can be compared to the word "present". Whatever you are doing right now is the state you are in. State of relaxation, state of anger,etc. every object has present, as well as a past (previous state) and a present (future state)
 
If you define a state as anything and everything then this other place you're are talking about doesn't even exist within the first place and the place you're referring to as void wouldn't even exist your argument collapses on itself.
 
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe RSPS Player
Two Factor Authentication User
In Memory of Jon
Christmas 2015
Doge
Halloween 2013
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Off Topic Participant
Gohan has AIDS
Heidy
Lawrence
PHP Shit Show 2k26
If Sythe doesn't provide a definition for state, we are not acting unfairly by providing our own (check follow up below). I define a state as anything and everything as well as everywhere. Therefor sythe must exist somewhere within everything and everywhere. The only place out of this would be void, which is an impossible place for anything to exist in, therefor sythe cannot be there.

Follow up: my definition of state is based on the fact that just as a human is in a state of conciousness, a star millions of light years away is in a state of energy or a atom is in a state of movement or a planet is in a state of rotation. Everything in the universe is in a state of something. A state can be compared to the word "present". Whatever you are doing right now is the state you are in. State of relaxation, state of anger,etc. every object has present, as well as a past (previous state) and a present (future state)


He stated that he wasn't speaking in a metaphysical sense.
 
To me, it seems like it works sort of like this:
You don't exist within a state because the state is a principle (that the moment a human being interacts with another human being, their actions should be moderated). But this doesn't really mean anything - what means something is that you will be coerced into acting a certain way, and punished or rewarded accordingly. So of course you will never experience a state, but you will experience its physical manifestation (the various limbs of the state).
So my point is that the existence of the state is a strange and almost counter-intuitive question (in the way it is being framed).
 
Two Factor Authentication User
SytheSteamer
Signature of the Month Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Christmas 2016
Christmas 2019
Easter 2016
Former OMM
In Memory of Jon
Member of the Month Winner
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
St. Patrick's Day 2018
Summer 2019
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Toast Wallet User
Verified Overwatch Diamond
Sythe, have you ever (after being of legal age) been in contact with the government, in such a condition that you have benefited from their uses?

Such as

-Received income tax after filing your taxes?
-Applied for a drivers licence?
-Taken part in a government funded program?
-Even purchased a Government funded Public transit pass?
 
You ought to clarify your non-existence. How can someone who doesn't exist or is non-existent even respond on a keyboard?
 
duelarena.gg
Back
Top