You're confused with review copies and actual verification. The OGV is set to verify guides, to make sure they're not just some old guide that someones trying to sell as their own, to show the legitimacy of the guide as it will have Sythe's OGV team's official verification.
In other words it was created for that sole purpose, to leave mods to worry about the site and us about guides.
So you are wrong. Only OGV can verify guides and its a huge difference from a simple review. As reviews don't prove the guide is original only that it works and that can be any guide.
And verification can be required when reports are made that it can be found for free.
I am suggesting requiring verification for 07 guides due to the fact that most of these are publicly available. Meaning you have no right to profit off it unless you add something different that isn't public. I never said all guides I said I would want to but its unrealistic knowing how ebook sellers take advantage of not requiring verification to rip off the ignorant otherwise the section would be dead and a few seller would remain (honest ones) but I see the conflict of worrying about too many knowing.
Publicly available means it anywhere online that its accessible.
Not sure what youre saying about writing a guide and not posting it. :huh:
I know how people selling ebooks are, there are the legit ones that have rights or actually made it themselves and then there are those looking to sell free ebook/methods to the ignorant for quick cash.
Sythe's opening of a ebook section opened a door to immoral people ready to prey on the ignorant, excusing their sales by saying its the buyers fault for not knowing.
In that case, I am still against requiring verification. Sellers shouldn't be prohibited from selling a guide they made just because they don't want to leak it to the OGV team.
If you have reports of someone selling a method that is publicly available , then just ask the buyer to describe and link to the public method, then ask the seller if that is the method, tell him he is not allowed to sell that guide if it is, if he tells you that is not the method and he continues to sell the guide, then someone else will report the him and you will be able to ban him.
"But what if the other buyer doesn't report him?"
Well if he is satisfied with the guide, good for both of them. No need to regulate or meddle anything, there is no conflict.
"But what if the other buyer is unsatisfied and fills a scam report? It could have been avoided"
Not really, if he fills a scam report, that means he went first, the seller could have just as well given him an empty guide, or just not give him anything at all,the OGV job is done and will aid in the banning of the illegitimate seller by determining that the guide sold was just as good as an empty guide .
Not only I think requiring verification is unnecessary, it would also be detrimental to someone who wants to sell a guide but doesn't want to leak it.
In short, nothing should be banned from being sold unless it is illegal.
False advertisement would be considered illegal.
Restrictions as to what guides someone is prohibited to sell should be linked to what he claims when he sells the guide.
Someone who made a thread titled "Selling Guide 5$", should be entitled to sell whatever guide he wants, even if it is public knowledge, however ridiculous it sounds.
Someone who made a thread titled "Selling 1m p/h Public knowledge moneymaking guide" should be entitled to sell a guide even if it is of public knowledge.
In the same sense, someone who makes a thread where he sells a method and never reveals what it is in the thread, while being secretive of its requirements and details, then it is clear that his intentions are to sell the guide as a secret method. If proven public knowledge, you could argue that is false advertisement.
However if the seller is clear about the requirements and all the details before selling, then there would be no reason for someone to buy the guide if they know it (because they'd know they know it obviously) and there would be no reason for a buyer to complain about it (because he obviously didn't know what the method was), and I wouldn't see any reason to prohibit the seller from selling more guides as long as he is the author of the guide.
No support for requiring verification.