• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Disagree with this ruling

Magic Arrow

Protector of the homosex, defender of the AIDS

$5 USD Donor
Mudkips
Retired Sectional Moderator
Joined
Feb 3, 2007
Sythe Gold
49
Messages
4,129
Location
Stuck in a Time Warp...."Hey look! It's
Extreme Homosex
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
A new sticky in RaS states
However sufficient reports without this requirement will still result in the account being banned until the situation is cleared up. But in order for the scammed user(s) to be eligible for reimbursement, there must be a Sythe PM.

I realise we're trying to protect sythe users from being unjustfully punished by hackers however, we must also provide a safety net for those being scammed. There has to be a median found which protects both parties.
 
Hmm. If the account is proven guilty of scamming, as is banned, why no reimbursement? I don't get it. It should be no ban / no reimbursement or ban / imbursement.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
If the user was negligent of receiving a PM, should we ban the sythe account for what happened on the skype account?
 
Extreme Homosex
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Should we reward the hacked user for being negligent with their Skype?
Same concept buddy
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
One of the skypes was even taken without the email. We can't punish people for the failures of the skype recovery system. IMO, anyway.
 
Extreme Homosex
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
One of the skypes was even taken without the email. We can't punish people for the failures of the skype recovery system. IMO, anyway.

Yes we can as we always have. All I'm saying is that there has to be a median.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Such as? Right now this seems the best solution.
 
Extreme Homosex
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Tbh this solution means only the scammers win. It causes more problems than it solves.

One thing id like to see implemented is an automated ban similar to the 5 point infraction where instead of banned tags the user receives hacked tags. The hacked writing is bolded, caps and red. So it'd look something like Magic arrow *HACKED DO NOT TRADE*. Give sectionals the ability to use it.

Secondly there should be at least a 50% reimbursement if there's no pm. Like it or not, it's still their Skype.
 
A new sticky in RaS states


I realise we're trying to protect sythe users from being unjustfully punished by hackers however, we must also provide a safety net for those being scammed. There has to be a median found which protects both parties.

I have to agree with you on this one, and while I can't suggest a suitable compromise I feel like there should be one made. There are always new users on Sythe, and they frequently get scammed by imposters and such - Obviously no refund is given in this case. However, when a person (purely for example, Elena) has their Skype hacked then it is essentially their fault for not having adequate security measures around their account, and surely they should be held accountable to some extent for the losses incurred by others.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
adequate security measures around their account

The problem is, there is no adequate measure besides purchasing from skype - which I only found out today after an hour long conversation with Skype on the LiveChat. One of the users was compromised despite having a registered email, without the email.

So potentially, we could all be compromised if we haven't made a skype purchase.
 
The problem is, there is no adequate measure besides purchasing from skype - which I only found out today after an hour long conversation with Skype on the LiveChat. One of the users was compromised despite having a registered email, without the email.

So potentially, we could all be compromised if we haven't made a skype purchase.

In that case, I would strongly suggest completely discontinuing the use of Skype on the site until they fix the security flaw. Otherwise EVERYONE will be hacked at some point or another.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
We can't punish users for what external programs they choose to use.. there's always been vulnerabilities in, for example, hotmail - but we can't say "don't use hotmail", only advise against it.

Right now we're advising keeping your skype private (disclosing via PM) and/or purchasing with skype to keep your account secure.
 
Penguin
MushyMuncher
Gohan has AIDS
Two Factor Authentication User
I think the ruling is fine as it is. Users should take the 3 fucking seconds it takes to request a pm and check the pm to make sure that they are not talking to a hacker/imposter. There are like 50 Threads in the RaS about popular people being scammers but in every one the person filing the report did not request a PM to verify they were talking to the correct person. If people would just request a PM while trading then a lot of the scams done would be avoided.

case and point... http://www.sythe.org/report-scammer/1550209-kmjt-scammer.html
 
Extreme Homosex
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
We can't punish users for what external programs they choose to use.. there's always been vulnerabilities in, for example, hotmail - but we can't say "don't use hotmail", only advise against it.

Right now we're advising keeping your skype private (disclosing via PM) and/or purchasing with skype to keep your account secure.

Skype just becomes a loophole for scammers. You guys are walking into very dangerous territory
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Requesting a PM should be standard practise for any trader.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Whether it should be standard practice or not, consider this scenario... Semper and I are good friends. He goes first to me on a 1b trade because he knows it's me, but doesn't need a PM because he can tell. Now, I was going to pay him... But since he never requested a PM, I now have an opportunity to scam him when I was actually going to pay him if he requested a PM.

This also leads to another point... What about people with no Sythe account, or banned? We can scam them freely and claim our Skype was hacked?
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
With Skype hackings going on, you should make it standard practise for everything from now on.

Obviously we'll investigate as much as we can to make sure the hacking claims are legitimate.
 
What's stopping people from pretending they were hacked after scamming someone who didn't ask for a PM? Yeah they'll be banned temporarily but once they claim they've regained control of their account they get off scot-free?

Is this how the new system works or am I missing something?
 
Back
Top