• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Question for Sythe in Regards to Stolen Goods

UWotM8?
<3 n4n0
Oktoberfest 2013
Village Drunk
Shitting Rainbow
Potamus
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
MushyMuncher
Justundude wasn't banned for selling duped gold, he was banned for selling duped gold and telling people it wasn't duped. The gold was at risk of being wiped from anyone who bought it, and he knew that which is why he was trying to dump on anybody who was foolish enough to buy it.

The shit he did made him a danger to the community.

Selling duped gold isn't against the rules, if someone wants to buy it that's their business, but don't trick people into buying it.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Halloween 2014
Detective
Christmas 2014
In Memory of Jon
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Justundude wasn't banned for selling duped gold, he was banned for selling duped gold and telling people it wasn't duped. The gold was at risk of being wiped from anyone who bought it, and he knew that which is why he was trying to dump on anybody who was foolish enough to buy it.

The shit he did made him a danger to the community.

Selling duped gold isn't against the rules, if someone wants to buy it that's their business, but don't trick people into buying it.

K but if I resell just un dude's duped gold without telling anyone it is duped because they didn't ask, would I be in the clear? That is what occurred during the crucible dupe which some slightly trusted members took part in here and the duelling dupe which matkias had offloaded to huge gold sellers here. Most people weren't aware of the first crucible dupe but the gold was sold and nobody was punished because nobody asked where it came from.

A portion of that 250bil which was off loaded here by gold sellers was also as equally risky.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
A portion of that 250bil which was off loaded here by gold sellers was also as equally risky.

This is true. That Matakias guy sold to loads to merchants here via PA/other methods, which was resold on Sythe and other sites. The gold was duped gold, which merchants knew about when buying. He dumped ~ 250B on PA within 2-3 days.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
K but if I resell just un dude's duped gold without telling anyone it is duped because they didn't ask, would I be in the clear? That is what occurred during the crucible dupe which some slightly trusted members took part in here and the duelling dupe which matkias had offloaded to huge gold sellers here. Most people weren't aware of the first crucible dupe but the gold was sold and nobody was punished because nobody asked where it came from.

A portion of that 250bil which was off loaded here by gold sellers was also as equally risky.

I am going to say that this would not be ok. Selling risky gold is not the same as selling stolen gold but it is along the same lines of sellers not disclosing information about their products. I definitely think it deserves a discussion.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
I am going to say that this would not be ok. Selling risky gold is not the same as selling stolen gold but it is along the same lines of sellers not disclosing information about their products. I definitely think it deserves a discussion.

If it resulted in bans/some form of punishment, then 90% of the known, reputable and top Market giants would be under fire.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Tier 1 Prizebox
Verified Challenger
Everyone knows who are the worst in this situation. The Chinese.

I could go to either of the top two advertisers on Sythe (Gold4fun / USFINE) and offer them gold, saying it was from hacked sources, and I guarantee they will still buy it.

If these rules apply to us, shouldn't they apply to the advertisers?
 
It is the Chinese who buy all of this for whatever without caring how it was obtained.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Everyone knows who are the worst in this situation. The Chinese.

I could go to either of the top two advertisers on Sythe (Gold4fun / USFINE) and offer them gold, saying it was from hacked sources, and I guarantee they will still buy it.

If these rules apply to us, shouldn't they apply to the advertisers?

I told Sythe that earlier aswell.

It would be close to impossible to actually contact the employers of the USFine/Gold4fun workers on Sythe and explain to them Sythe's stance on stolen golds. I highly doubt telling 3rd-party companies how to run their business would go smoothly however.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Tier 1 Prizebox
Verified Challenger
Please wait for a site operator to respond. Please don't forget to leave your feedback when this chat end.

You are now chatting with 'Sara'

none: hey
none: sara
Sara: Hello,how may I help you today?
none: i sell 500m EOC
none: $50
none: need sell fast
none: can?
none: $0.10/m lol
Sara: $125 for 500m
none: i will sell for $50
none: can you buy now?
Sara: i can buy now,but payment in 2 days
none: ok, can you do paypal?
Sara: yes
none: i hacked my friend for it i have to sell right away
none: where to meet?
Sara: what ???
Sara: you hacked from others??
none: yes, my friend
Sara: then we won't buy it
none: for $50?
Sara: no
none: :(
none: so i cant sell?
Sara: no
none: ok nvm it is not hacked
none: where do we meet?
Sara: are you member
none: not member
none: can do w19?
none: need fast
Sara: i am logging
none: before my acct recovered back
none: ok
none: name?
Sara: i can go to member world only
none: ok fine world 28
none: name plz?
Sara: you said you are not member ?
none: i can make member
none: its fine
none: takes me 1 minute
none: where to meet
none: my RSN: bojang1
Sara: Burthorpe
none: what world
Sara: w28
none: ok
none: you there now?
Sara: yes
Sara: 10snowsteal
Sara: this is name

GOLD4FUN Live Chat, literally RIGHT NOW.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Tier 1 Prizebox
Verified Challenger
So as we can see, when I directly said I hacked my friend, they said no they won't buy it. TWO MINUTES later, however, I just have to say "nvm it's not hacked" and they're ready to trade again. Then I even throw in "hurry up before my account is recovered" just to show how obvious that it is hacked gold.

Bottom line, for this rule to truly take effect, it needs to be enforced forum-wide.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Tier 1 Prizebox
Verified Challenger
I guarantee I can convince any Chinese gold site to buy hacked / stolen GP.
 

Because they themselves knew it was duped gold, still chose to buy it and resell it to others. They KNEW what it was and where it'd come from but yet still sold it.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Halloween 2014
Detective
Christmas 2014
In Memory of Jon
Paper Trading Competition Participant
I guarantee I can convince any Chinese gold site to buy hacked / stolen GP.

If the price is right I can convince almost all large gold traders/ sellers on here to buy the gold whether it is duped, scammed, or hacked and none of them are willingly going to state their gold came from a dupe or illegal methods if I were to buy it off of them.

Also R2P that chat was a good read, I kind of read it in a Chinese accent.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Tier 1 Prizebox
Verified Challenger
Our company will not accept gold if you say it is hacked / scammed. I will be going over that further with all our employees today just to make sure they are aware. What I'm saying is, the big sites do not have the same oversight.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Halloween 2014
Detective
Christmas 2014
In Memory of Jon
Paper Trading Competition Participant
What if they don't say where it is from? If the question is overlooked then technically you unknowingly bought the gold and according to the rule you would only be banned if the person had told you it was hacked or scammed but really who is going to say they hacked and scammed gold, if the people here don't buy it the Chinese in the advertisements will. Also if that gold was proven to be scammed or hacked and the person who it was hacked from later came to realize you had his gold would you be responsible to pay? Since that gold is hacked, you unknowingly bought it, and the hacked victim wants compensation what would happen? I understand Sythe said case by case but nobody wants to get into a situation like this where they won't know the outcome.

Also how far down the trade chain does the gold become legally obtained? If I bought gold off somebody and they told me they hacked it after the fact would I be responsible to disclose that and tell my buyer they might be responsible to pay back the victim who was originally hacked should he come forward and want compensation, to relate to a real life situation if my car was stolen and later sold to somebody I would get my car back and even if it was sold 2 or 3 times after the original theft I would get my car back and the last guy would be out of luck since the other sellers before him apart from the thief didn't know the car was stolen or at least weren't told it was.

Situations like the above will arise frequently so a decision would be nice on who holds the responsibility.
 
UWotM8?
<3 n4n0
Oktoberfest 2013
Village Drunk
Shitting Rainbow
Potamus
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
MushyMuncher
K but if I resell just un dude's duped gold without telling anyone it is duped because they didn't ask, would I be in the clear? That is what occurred during the crucible dupe which some slightly trusted members took part in here and the duelling dupe which matkias had offloaded to huge gold sellers here. Most people weren't aware of the first crucible dupe but the gold was sold and nobody was punished because nobody asked where it came from.

A portion of that 250bil which was off loaded here by gold sellers was also as equally risky.

If proof had been shown that Just un dude had told these people that it was duped gold, and then someone had come forward saying that those resellers had lied to them saying it wasn't duped gold, they would have been banned as well.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Halloween 2014
Detective
Christmas 2014
In Memory of Jon
Paper Trading Competition Participant
If proof had been shown that Just un dude had told these people that it was duped gold, and then someone had come forward saying that those resellers had lied to them saying it wasn't duped gold, they would have been banned as well.

So there's no need to disclose the information whether it is harmful or not unless it is asked? Basically just overlook the origins and you will be fine. That portion of the 250bil was being sold by resellers here quite a while before roy and just un caught on. The crucible dupe done by members here was not forced to be disclosed even though some members reached close to 1 bil gold at the time, basically my question is if the question isn't asked but you know of the origins and potential harm can you be punished since the right question wasn't asked?
 
UWotM8?
<3 n4n0
Oktoberfest 2013
Village Drunk
Shitting Rainbow
Potamus
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
MushyMuncher
So there's no need to disclose the information whether it is harmful or not unless it is asked? Basically just overlook the origins and you will be fine. That portion of the 250bil was being sold by resellers here quite a while before roy and just un caught on. The crucible dupe done by members here was not forced to be disclosed even though some members reached close to 1 bil gold at the time, basically my question is if the question isn't asked but you know of the origins and potential harm can you be punished since the right question wasn't asked?

We can't prove that they knew the origins of the gold, we can only assume such. Unlike Just un dude who we had undeniable proof that he was selling duped gold and lying about it.
 
Back
Top