Xbox problems?

I have a Xbox 360 and it's fairly new. It works fine and every game plays correctly except black ops 2. I bought a used black ops 2 today for my brother and it wouldn't play in my Xbox. I figured the disk was messed up so I went to gamestop and traded it for another used copy of the game. Which also would not work. It would start but would freeze every time at the main menu. So I took it back to gamestop again and traded it and paid an extra 10$ and got a NEW copy of the game. It still doesn't work in my xbox? All other games work fine and I've never had this problem. Anuone have this problem before or know how resolve it?

 

I had that happen to my MW2 way back in 2009 what I did was cleaned it very well with a cloth and also cleaned the front side near the inner circle area which made it work but the fact that you got another copy of it and it didn't works leads me to think this isn't the case.