Water have life?

I just search some information on water and come across this: http://www.life-enthusiast.com/twilight/research_emoto.htm

Do you believe from this research or you think its a fake?

Discuss.

I personally think it is hard to believe.

 

Water doesn't live. It's inanimate, lifeless. Water is H2O, which are just 3 molecules connected to eachother.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_(molecule)

 

Have you read my article? Life as in respond to you. Not that literally "life".

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masaru_Emoto#Water_crystal_work_and_criticism

Not exactly rigorous science, is it?

 

I've skimmed the article. I thought you mean life, as in, knowing what it does.
I don't really know how that Emoto guy gets those crystals the way they are, but I think it has something to do with the environment, air pressure, temperature, humidity, etc.

 

But some things cant be explain. All I ask is if you believe it or not. Maybe you believe in a scientific approach. For example why are you borned in America and not in Russia? Why? You can't explain all this can't you?

 

I disbelieve in all things until they can be proven.

Emoto is not using the scientific method at all. His data is incomplete, and his results are probably biased. It would be jumping the gun to try to draw any conclusions at this point.

I had to be born somewhere, didn't I?

 

Well..Lets say that you didn't proof it "scientifically" about where would you be born and how come you were born in 1990 for example, that does not mean I don't believe your existence even if you're born in 2010.

About the data, maybe you or we do an experiment and see if its true.

 

I honestly have no idea what you just said.

Water is made up of elements which are not living. Therefore water could not be living, could it? Do you see water walking around, and breathing, NO.
If you could explain your past few posts (because honestly, your english is ghastly, and I don't know what your saying) I could furthermore discuss this. As of now I find this thread incredibly stupid.

 

Water is not life, it is what basically spurs life on.

 

If I knew you in real life, you would probably believe me about my age because:

- I don't lie.
- I have documentation to prove it.
- I look my age.

You seem to be mixing up "proving beyond a reasonable doubt" (which is what Emoto has to do) and "proving beyond any and all doubts, realistic or not".

 

Not only that, but they can check your age scientificly by looking at your teeth. Ever heard of wisdom teeth?

 

I dont think it does. Yet some people (including my dumb science teacher) think it does. But, i guess thats why he gets paid $30,000 a year l0l.

Some people could consider it life though. Like when/if they find water on mars. Some people would say they found life on mars, some people would say they found the same junk that takes up 75% of our continent. I guess it depends which way you look at it though.

 

I had a almost 2 hours discussion about this experiment in school.
Emoto is just wrong with his conclusion. Ice crystals never are the same and form different according to various external conditions.
In the end this just a way to make more money.

 

When he is born is down to when his parents had sexual intercourse, and how successful fertilisation was. What're you trying to say? A person's existence starts from conception, unless you have the religious or moral belief that someone's a person after a certain stage in the pregnancy... what you said makes absolutely no sense, in that, if he is born in 2010, he doesn't exist yet, unless you believe in a different plane, whether spiritual or w/e.