[Special Dispute] Badger191 #2

*It has been over a month and it seems as though the staff has forgotten about my previous dispute, that is why I am posting this one.*

I have been banned for almost a year now, I think 9 months to be exact, and I am now re-posting my previous dispute as I feel that I was banned unjustly. During this time away from Sythe I would first like to say that I have 'ban evaded' (I don't remember the username) but it was to post on the "Finn is Dishonest" thread and I openly stated that I was badger191 and was banned on that account promptly.

As some of you may, or may not know I've banned under the assumption of self-vouching. The account that I've supposedly self-vouched was 'Depend' (http://www.sythe.org/member.php?u=192506) who is a real life friend of mine. As I've told Tyro, Depend and I have been on Sythe at the same time in the same house, and hes' been at mine and I've been at his - This is where the problem lies.

Here are the vouches:
1. http://www.sythe.org/showpost.php?p=...9&postcount=10
2. Asking to MM a trade for 'Depend' - http://gnu.sythe.org/showthread.php?p=4388519
3. http://www.sythe.org/showthread.php?...74#post5147974

I have provided the staff with IRL information so they are able to check whatever they need to check.

Problem 2 - *Too many accusations of scamming?*

In my conversation with Tyro he brought up five threads in the report a scammer section:
1. http://www.sythe.org/showpost.php?p=...2&postcount=31
2. http://sythe.org/showthread.php?t=546668
3. http://sythe.org/showthread.php?t=543595
4. http://sythe.org/showthread.php?p=4496292
5. http://www.sythe.org/showthread.php?t=529284

1. Person claims I scammed him without proof, probably was an impostor.
2, 3, 4. Same person, this was the 3-way trade that I can explain
5. A leecher calling me a scammer.

Tryo stated "somehow, I doubt all of these run-ins are coincidental", and "all of your bad trades (and successful impostors, who, for some reason, choose to impersonate a market mod) make me less likely to believe your story"

~Apparently, because I'm a market mod it undermines the possibility of an impostor? That is absolute garbage, you can look around the MM forums or anyone with a successful business and they'd have just as many impostors. Tyro is only stating this as he claims to only of had one impostor.

Explaination of links 2,3,4:

This is a confusing, long trade. It was a three-way trade for World of Warcraft accounts. r0fl owned pl0x traded 'cswilson/Nikor0x' his lvl 72 Death Knight, For his lvl 80 Warlock. Wilson then trades the 72 Death Knight to me. r0fl owned pl0x's warlock got recovered, not by cswilson, and tells him that he will be recovering the death knight. This would mean that r0fl owned pl0x would be recovering MY new death knight even though I was not part of this trade; I refused. I would not let go of my new DK and r0fl owned pl0x and cswilson started to team against my and attempt to get me banned.

Jcash claiming I scammed him -
Though I had already discussed this with him via PM, I'll explain the story once more. I had purchased an account from a Sythe user who originally purchased it from Chancelere(Spelling?) and I was not told that it was Perm-Muted. After finding out that the account was perm-muted I decided to re-sell it, and Jcash had purchased it. I'm not saying that the account was not recovered, it probably was, but I'm saying that I was not the one who had recovered the account.

Now, if I'm correct here is what I'm banned for:

1. A friend vouching for me (one of the vouches even states he is my friend, and I've supplied information to the staff) - There was a period where everyone was given time to confess for lesser consequences, if I had really self-vouched I would of posted there as Gohan did.

2. Having too many scam reports - I don't think this is even a valid reason AT ALL since none of them are valid.

3. Having too many impostors - This is not a good reason either.

Even if you don't believe that 'Depend' is my IRL friend I've yet to understand why it's a permanent ban while other people charged with the crime of self-vouching, specifically Plznate, get off after one month - I asked this to Tyro and his response was "we don't typically unban people after a "friend" vouches from them from the same IP address 2 minutes after a trade". - I find this to be quite stupid as even though you don't believe me you would ban me for self-vouching, no? Why is my case different than any other users?

Contributions to the Site
Though you might not believe it, I have contributed quite a lot to this website from cleaning the spam forum, catching scammers/evaders, stopping people from impostors, and MM'ing. I've MM'ed many trades, and even been on accounts with well over 2B RSGP and nothing had been touched. As Sythe's longest sectional (Not sure if I still hold this) I firmly believe that I was considered a trusted member of the community. If you would like to contact someone who I've spent a lot of time with, please contact either Spyike, or Video.

Additional notes:
I would love to have this appeal read by Richard or Matthew, if it not possible that is fine. I appologize if I have caused any trouble when I was first banned; I was just extremely angry for being banned for no valid reason and having Finn handle my pardon even though I requested that he did not. Finn, I have no hard feelings for you anymore.

If you've got any questions please contact me - [email protected] (My old MSN won't let me log in to it anymore so I am now using this one).

 

Do not create multiple disputes.