What do you think of my first sig?

Hey Guys,

This is the first sig i've ever made! I didnt know which version was best so im gna put all 4 up for Constructive Criticism

I hope you guys enjoy it I know it was a pain in the ass for me to make these especially after my first 5 sigs failed miserably!



EDIT: Here's Second Sig!



Fonts Changed:





Text Color Changed:







Let me know which one looks best!

EDIT: New Sig

 

I like the fourth one!
The others; in my opinion, have too much colour to them. Too much of that hue. That's what it looks like you did. Took that image and applied a hue/saturation overlay to it. I much like the final one though. It all flows nicely.

 

I like the fourth one, but out of curiosity what was the original image?
Also, stay away from text for now. It kills the tags.

 

The fourth, cause its ambient is darker than all the others.
I also like the yellow touch in the 3rd.

 

Thx guys, i changed teh gradient map colors not hue/saturation. Btw changed the text cuz my cousin told me it was too much so i updated a bit ill post the updates now.

 

But does teh tag look good?

 

Good job for your first sig, I like the one you currently are using. The other is too dark.

 

Yeah, but the text partially ruins it. Was it a stock image or a render?

 

Thank you!

ya i know text kills it, im not good with text at all...and they were both renders.

 

Amazing for a first tag then, the first image. The second one is decent smudging.

 

ya i know the second one didnt turn out so well, i messed up and just kept going to fix it, for a fuck up it didnt turn out so bad.