• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

  • *ATTENTION* Threads posted in this section are hidden until approved by a staff member. You can also post as a guest by clicking "Post New Thread." Thank you.

[SECOND OPINION] Request Unban McMarina

  • Thread starter Thread starter Unregisteredmcmarinaunban
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
U

Unregisteredmcmarinaunban

Guest
Sorry about sending in another appeal. I've spoken to Dave and he said it was okay, as my initial one this morning was a bit hot headed as I had just gotten out of bed to find out I was banned.

323038 - JarvisPK
264497 - blittzye
353952 - hammers
294738 - tommmmm


I would like to open a dispute about my account McMarina being banned in hope of it being unbanned.
The evidence put against me can be found here in this thread http://www.sythe.org/report-ban-evader/1787194-mcmarina-ban-evader-25-donor-svu.html

I will address each part of Bus369's report bit by bit.

''Link to current Sythe account: http://www.sythe.org/members/355962-mcmarina.html

Link to banned Sythe account(s): http://www.sythe.org/members/353952-hammers.html

http://www.sythe.org/members/264497-blittzye.html

http://www.sythe.org/members/323038-jarvispk.html ''

Funnily enough I am also linked to another banned account 'tommmmm' (user ID 294738).

Here is a list of the accounts and ip addresses I am linked to
rkydll.png



'Why you think they are ban evading (just an IP audit match is NOT ENOUGH!:

a post by jarvis:
(PP) Selling Maxed Staker (RSGP)

a post by mcmarina:
http://www.sythe.org/other-services/...800k-hour.html'

As my university lecturers would say 'be more critical/what does this mean?'

This is irrelavent, so what that this guy sold a maxed main however long ago it was in RS3? My account wasn't even made until Oldschool came about, especially considering my login includes 'nmz' short for nightmare zone, and was something brought it for Oldschool(happy to proce. Not linked, just a coincidence, and actually a poor attempt at linking us together.

''I managed to resolve his current IP, however every single skype that the banned accounts have been linked to I cant seem to resolve(what are the odds that 3 diff skypes with 3 diff owners(supposedly) cant be resolved when everyone elses can?

Especially when it just so happens these 3 accounts are the only ones her/his audit turns up.

Something Seems Wrong.

It also seems that all of these accounts are involved in the account market at some point or another(just scanning through each ones posts/threads).

hammers-joins 9/26/12

marina-joins 10/21/12

Edit: found another skype by hammer I still cant resolve''

That is exactly the case. We are all different people. 'Especially when it just so happens these 3 accounts are the only ones her/his audit turns up.' This part really made me mad. Considerng Bus's justification of this was
'Also notice how ever account hammers audit links to is banned besides mcmarina:' The accounts that are banned, linked to mine, all have been linked to me on separate ip addresses. Whether it was been while i've been on my mobile or while i've been travelling and been on different computers/networks. This is a reasonable arguement considering 'tommmmm' was not an account in question when Bus opened their report. And has probably been linked with me since I was posting from my mobile from where I had travelled to; most likely on christmas day!

55413d.png


The photo above is of the audit checks for each account linked to mine. All are linked to me from different ip addresses, apart from blittzye and JarvisPK. However if you were to look at their audits both of them only posted from this location once also, but have posted from the same location several times in different places (have a look at the audits yourself) which means those accounts were probably linked together but mine? Just as much as the other 10-20 accounts on their audit checks when they were posting when roaming. As it goes for hammers; JarvisPK, blittzye and tommmmm are not linked to each other and as it goes for tommmmm; JarvisPK, blittzye and hammers are not linked to each other.


I'd like to think I've put forward a supporting arguement this is all just a coincidence. Please can the mods be considerate of my appeal as much as they have been to Bus's report.
 
Pool Shark
Village Drunk
<3 n4n0
Battleship Champion
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Well, this was one hell of a dispute, but I've looked into Bus369's report in addition to your dispute.

Bus369 resolved your Skype ID to an IP address. This matched your account. Hardly a coincidence.

As for the banned accounts and their Skype(s), I don't see it being a coincidence that they are unable to be resolved.
The user accounts are banned and the Skype ID's most likely went inactive as a result (sign of a serial vader).

The IP match found between you and Hammers resolves to the ISP "Three".
I looked into this and found that "Three" is more regularly known as "Three UK", which is a phone service provider that generally gets bad reviews...
The same holds true for the IP match with blittzye and JarvisPK.

As a result, I'm deducing that your ban was given in error.

I will need a second opinion in order to request an unban.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Runescape Gamblingrunescape gambling
Back
Top