Sale Problem

[clydefrawg]

I sold an account to Lebokiller (http://www.sythe.org/members/425568-lebokiller.html), after a day he messaged me saying it was recovered. He showed me some pictures and it was enough for me to believe him. I went on to try and get the information back for him and I received this

What is the proper procedure to continue here? Do I refund him? Give him a new account? I've never been in this situation before.

 

Do as you wish, work it out with him if you really believe it's been recovered, but know that people can easily edit emails/whatever