Recording Xbox 360 Gameplay

Should I get HD PVR or BLack Magic Intensity?

Intensity: http://www.blackmagic-design.com/products/intensity/



HD PVR: http://www.hauppauge.com/site/products/data_hdpvr.html



​

Well sir, what game type are you recording? Modern Warfare 2
How long? usually like 15 mins, and then start again recording, like in between matches.
Voice? nah,
Output to where? My laptop and when I said black magic intensity, I meant the intensity shuttle, so It can goto any computer with USB 3.0

 

Well sir, what game type are you recording?
How long?
Voice?
Output to where?

Please include more information, thanks!

 

updated thread with the information

 

It seems that they are both amazing in graphics, more than you'll be needing.
As in customer satisfaction via word of mouth, I've heard that both products work well enough for the price tag. I've heard more about your first option.
The intensity, apparently works very well because it is universal. If you're looking to record tons of things and upload form various sources, this is your best bet.
On the other hand, if you're going for the purely MW2 to YouTube experience, then the PVR is the way to go. It doesn't do much else, but you won't find better.

 

I would buy the Intensity Shuttle tbh. The HDPVR doesn't have HDMI as far as I know, whereas the Shuttle does. I'm pretty sure you also don't need super fast HDDs to use the Shuttle like you do the PCIe version (BMI Pro or w/e).

They're essentially the same cost and you get more features on the Shuttle, seems like the best choice. Just make sure you have USB 3.0 because the Shuttle requires it.