Here's my update/ installment in the case 'Riskfighter v. Marcellus1404's Anus'
First I'd like to say sorry (the evidence is clear) but because of it's volume you probably missed a lot of key information and I would like to apologize. I expect a full refund now after finding even more evidence looking back. Another issue is Marcellus has not explained or responded to any real evidence I showed him. He just ignores it and makes random unsubstantiated claims that shouldn't mean anything, but this depth in showing his wrongs should leave him with nothing to strawman.
1) Agreeing to pay for supplies:
He should pay for the second bond as well since he took longer than promised (I provided the first bond).
You should find some information and confirmation in our SYTHE conversation that I believe he deleted (see 2).
Gyazo - d0e2c4bf1f4c47baea80893b5f23951f.png
2) Sythe conversations that have been deleted. We had a confirmation of service on SYTHE with chat from our SKYPE's. This conversation on SYTHE I can no longer find.
Gyazo - 276415a2875ed5e899431499fa82673a.png
'what's on sythe as our agreement incriminates me, shit! lemme go delete it!'
side note:
Gyazo - 80ba05999d30a17cbf38585c3b6085e9.png
where I tell him to follow the quest requirements so I don't have to go back and do stuff myself after. It's been almost one month since he started the service and I still have to go and hire someone else to do the quests. That is what I mean by wasting my time, if not by him lying and forcing me to uncover evidence. This along with evidence I show throughout and after warrant a fair consideration. If I am refunded full, however, he does not need to compensate me extra.
3a) The evidence I had before he made his self-admissions is below also, however showing his admission is way simpler than showing every step (that corresponds with evidence) until conclusion, when this evidence is from dozens of different places. BOTH come to the same conclusion, though and the latter is not as comprehensive or detailed, it is more just pointing out he admits to it after lying for weeks and validates my conclusion.
Self-admission of guilt 1- hiring others when he said he did NOT
After weeks of pretending to do the service himself, Marcellus gets into an argument with me. As we know, people usually come to conclusions with premises they believe true. Here, Marcellus uses a truth (that he used someone else without my permission) to substantiate a point he was making (that he removed gp before using him as the people he used before hacked the account because he didn't).
By trying to argue with me, he accidentally uses the truth (that he used someone else) to argue a different point and says 'fuck' because he admitted it accidentally as a premise in another conclusion.
Self-admission of guilt 2- Looking through our messages: looks like Marcellus DID admit to hiring someone for thieving, while not following protocol he described. As I show in later evidence, he self-admits to him believing my hack was
from someone he hired and that story changes.
Gyazo - 3ca3c8c658f3c03fcc09ed78efb96cda.png
Here I present him my conclusion with a (to him, he's not that perceptive) hidden premise that he hired someone previously. However, he admits to hiring someone (WTF?) saying I gave him permission (I as much gave him permission as I did not, and he is using that to make his argument and confuse everyone).
HOWEVER/REGARDLESS:
1) clearly he did not tell me to change the password (why the account got hacked)
2) we know on 3/21 Anti was clearly working on the account, which proves he is lying about this
3) where are the screenshots, even after he has admitted to hiring someone after lying?
He says to me 'with your permission, yes'... So... I gave you permission to hire someone else to a job without screenshots, that I paid you to do with YOUR OWN MONEY. I clearly made an issue about it because it makes the most sense for ME TO HIRE SOMEONE WHO OWES ME WORK FOR FREE but TAKE IT OUT OF HIS OVERALL PAYMENT.
This is where he really screwed me, because HE GOT THE THIEVING SERVICE COMPLETELY FREE ANYWAY and he effectively did nothing for my payment. HE ALSO WASTED THE FREE, TRUSTED SERVICE I COULD HAVE GOTTEN SINCE THE PERSON WHO OWES ME COULD HAVE DONE IT. I DROPPED THE ISSUE BECAUSE HE SAID HE WOULD DO IT HIMSELF, AND WOULD INFORM ME IF HE DID WANT TO HIRE SOMEONE ELSE.
Gyazo - 7cc104b86f6afca8c6f578e7728cea5f.png
Gyazo - 84051b9b71942a712200213d8036fa9a.png
The uncertainty with one of the statements is that I put all risk on him because I try convincing him that it's not worth using someone untrusted since it risks all the work he did so far, meaning it is better to secure the time already spent instead of wasting it.
I STILL I LOSE TIME, MY ACCOUNT, and EFFORT I PUT MYSELF. This is NOT a term of service in ANY WAY. He has ALREADY STATED HE WILL DO IT HIMSELF. That is me REASSURING THAT HE IS DOING THE SMARTEST THING BY NOT PAYING FOR UNTRUSTED WORK and NOT A TOS or whatever BS he has cooked up. ASK why he lied about literally everything? Because HE KNEW it was my INTENT that he did the work HIMSELF and ALL EVIDENCE POINTS to this, including his lying. THIS IS OVERCOMPLICATION ON HIS SIDE EVEN THOUGH HE KNOWS HE IS WRONG, and ultimately another reason I want a full refund because he is stringing you along and making me spend so much time. His claims without real substantial evidence are wasting everyone's time.
3B) Evidence for terms to hiring others:
Gyazo - 9153a5ca2d71de1013d318562f9fdce2.png
That is also where I try getting him to understand that by hiring others for a job I paid him to do, I AM EFFECTIVELY PAYING FOR IT, NOT HIM. I am LOOKING FOR SPECIFICS ON WHO IS DOING THE JOB because I HAVE A FRIEND WHO OWES ME WORK (will do it for FREE himself that I TRUST). This is a breaking point in Marcellus's core argument, that I gave permission for him to hire others. I DID NOT explicitly say NO OR YES. That is because:
- I was under the impression he was still looking for it since that is what people do, and he's been generally unprepared and late, and I assume he will look for someone to do the job AFTER I give permission. No where do I explicitly GIVE HIM PERMISSION either. I am accepting his statements, not giving explicit permission. Marcellus is NOW USING THE VAGUE NATURE OF THIS CONVERSATION WHERE HE CHANGES POSITIONS, TO SAY I GAVE HIM PERMISSION. HOWEVER, THE ISSUE IS BEYOND EVEN THAT.
- I was still looking for more information to make the best decision
- By changing HIS intentions (going to hire someone first, then AGREEING it is a bad idea and will do it himself), the meaning of his messages CHANGED, while mine DID NOT.
MOVING PAST THAT ARGUMENT and pointing out, REGARDLESS of whether or not I gave permission Marcellus DID say explicitly:
1) he would tell me to change the password after to something only the two of us know
- this never happened, and he DOES ADMIT LATER TO HIRING OTHERS.
- AS A RESULT OF NOT FOLLOWING PROPER PROTOCOL, my account was hacked
2) he would ONLY do this for thieving
- we know this is not true (self admission 1,2 + further evidence)
3) he would pay 2.5m
-as Mahi said only a mere few hours ago (
https://www.sythe.org/conversations/38-53-thieving-order-for-marcellus1404.5827149/ ) , the service was free and Marcellus tipped afterwards with a vouch where he LIKELY ASKED MAHI TO OMIT INFORMATION AROUND PAYMENT, OR SAY THAT MARCELLUS PAID AFTERWARDS MAKING IT UNCLEAR WHETHER THE SERVICE WAS PAID OR A TIP. This distinction Marcellus has tried to hide, clearly shows the nature of his omissions and cover ups, and directly implicates himself here.
3c) Timing of My Complaints:
This is another point I want to get out of the way. I had 0 suspicions before 3/20 (day I was hacked). In fact, the
only thing that happened was me being annoyed by his inefficiency and communication skills. I thought that by being exactingly clear with him would minimize that (I mean, what else am I supposed to do) and that problem would go away. My understanding was that time issues can't really be done anything about, especially if
some progress
has made on the account. I was fine with him being slow when he pushed at first (again, I paid him a bit less than what others offered to do for, human nature if he values other projects higher). So I'm only annoyed now that he extended the deadline 4-5+ times, HE STILL DIDN'T DO ANYTHING PROPERLY. I would like this to be submitted as evidence of his character (does not hold himself accountable or responsible for other, smaller things).
I found real issues on 3/20, the same day I got hacked. However, I'll be honest. I was exhausted and just went to sleep. I didn't complain then, because I had every reason to believe him until he made no sense. Either way, this is what set me off. Looking back I remember I was literally about to close my eyes and fall asleep when he sent those messages. I changed the password, tried getting some information about what happened, and passed out:
Gyazo - ac4bb22345d74da14705763922277ac8.png
Gyazo - 47e0337a7fb644acff1e030b7d5f8766.png
This next screenshot is after I send him the new password. Here he says it is someone he knows, but now he contradicts that with 'I think it was someone who did a service for me'. Meaning, someone he hired, did not tell me, or take items out. The next day you can see me messaging him and he has his private off the day after I tell him to keep them open. The same day I raise issues (hopefully now you understand Azie. Wasn't a big deal at first, it stood out, I asked him, he had an excuse but I told him not to do it again and he agreed. After he broke his agreement I took it up with you. When it happened first, it was just abnormal but with his excuse that makes some sense I didn't bother.)
Notice when and where he says 'ummm' it indicates him lying or trying to make something up.
Gyazo - 0cd32b7152a353255b5d8838df221a96.png
The next day (3/21, day after the hack) after coming home I went out and looked for advice, and came into contact with you. With only 1 day (night/school) in between, I don't think it is fair to make a point against action for me (infact, hours, since I got hacked at night).
I only have so much evidence and a comprehensive conclusion because of the length of time Marcellus dragged our trial out. As I have shown, every time I examine the evidence I find something new (I find more to write about as I look at the evidence again, even now). This volume of exposure has made the amount of information I know to be so much, not because I had suspicions before 3/21, but because I keep looking at it everytime I send it. It is also easily accessible, all one needs to do is look at his profile. This is me contacting you on 3/21
Gyazo - 9026bd962f350f1a698f7bef85784afa.png
Marcellus accepting responsibility for the hack:
Gyazo - 9357cca8f5c5299999ab1d05eb2ee7a8.png
Also I would like to make this point extremely clear, because Marcellus is getting into everyone's head:
I HAVE 0 'SUSPICIONS'. I have evidence. EVIDENCE IS EVIDENCE, NOT SUSPICION regardless of what Marcellus says. I MADE THESE CLAIMS and conclusions BECAUSE THERE IS EVIDENCE to make them. I have the other PARTY ADMITTING TO DO THE JOB. Marcellus is just trying to confuse everyone because he thinks making it more complicated will demotivate me, and I will end up paying. I started making complaints when I had evidence to be suspicious, then sure, of what I am saying (when evidence adds up to a conclusion that I can be confident of).
My suspicion is so 'strong' because I open Marcellus's posts and find him looking for free work directly, asking someone, receiving it, and then getting a tip for it- I thought it was free, Marcellus said he would be paying 2.5m when he first told me about it. As I'm typing this I receive a message from the guy who did the thieving (Mahi) who took so long replying due to a family death. As you can see I sent Mahi a message 3/23/17. This should simultaneously dissolve Marcellus's claims that Anti (the latest person, the one who gave me evidence first) was my friend previous to finding him working on my account. Find our messages here:
https://www.sythe.org/conversations/38-53-thieving-order-for-marcellus1404.5827149/#message-8545726
Here are the people who I HAVE EVIDENCE worked on the account:
Mahi- 38-53 thieving
Radihv- 18-40 mining, 20-30 agility, 30-38 thieving
Doing free short services!
- my account started with 18 mining when I gave it to Marcellus, the quest 'A Feud' should give enough experience for 30 thieving, this is why I believe he did work on my account also.
Mr Wolf- 36-48 agility
Combat/Skilling/Quest/ Services [Free & Cheap]
Anti- finished mining to 60, crafting to 61, magic to 65, 40-55 woodcutting which Marcellus was looking for.
Anti has kindly supplied me with his conversations with Marc:
Imgur: The most awesome images on the Internet
Proof that it's Marcellus1404's id:
Screenshot
Here Marcellus posts looking for free services on the same day
Woodcutting:
WTB 40-55 Woodcutting
Likely mining:
Offering unlimited free servicing.
Agility:
♕ #1 Agility Service! ♕ Nmz 5 GP/XP! Fast✔Hand Done✔ ♕
His vouches where I could find these people:
Marcellus1404 Vouches
My suspicions, however: he COULD have gotten people to log onto his OSBUDDY, he COULD have gotten a million things done THROUGH SKYPE where I have no access.
This is where I find out that other people are working on the account, on 3/21, when Anti (the person he hired) pm's me:
Gyazo - d6ea6df2d03592c418f25f8bcefaab85.png
Gyazo - 4e7f329cbe324b36b7f0c06dd5bdfc3a.png
Note: I am speaking that way because I thought he was being scammed somehow too.
Also: this is only the evidence I have from sythe and skype. Marcellus could have done anything through SKYPE and not share or have that information see the light of day.
I also PM you the same day, and everything I compiled above is a result of Marcellus being difficult and having me look through everything I can, NOT a result of suspicions previously (as is your standing assumption). I have had 2 weeks to look through this.
HOWEVER: I WAS cautious of his character and intelligence as I DID see this, his previous scam reports where he messes up, denies it's his fault/refuses responsibility, then expects to get paid because he still did the work:
REPORTING Itslitbruh
Reporting marcellus1404
There's nothing reasonable to report in the early or middle, even nearing the end of the service, as the above is presumably instanced until proven otherwise. This is me proving otherwise and showing Marcellus's contradictions. His motivation, in line with the previous scam report is clear:
Marcellus confused the job even after delaying it 4 or 5 times. Let's be clear, he didn't finish it and I am not reporting this information once the job is done. It has been almost one month and a service that should have been done with in 1 week is still not finished.
OTHER CONSIDERABLE EVIDENCE:
1)So is this Marcellus saying 'Yes I was/am clueless, deduct some for that'
Gyazo - a52d6d437799dc53cef6fb4cdd47433d.png
2)After I made this an issue he started doing stuff like this: (reason for submission is evidence on decisions he makes/ his thought process)
Gyazo - d8da4dcd2c81ba9d591f419eeeadb65c.png
I need to prove that I didn't use the supplies on the account? I proceed to add up what he could have spent the money on and he says 'see how messy you have made this all become'. This is another way of saying, 'I'm going to make anything I can an issue and make it messy to prove a point and be spiteful' -- we both agreed he would pay for supplies and he unnecessarily starts drama.
3)He thinks paying other people without my knowledge can be construed as his 'supplies' for doing the job (WTF?):
Gyazo - 7a29268099815a6f2c3bded06be5d2ab.png
4)He thinks because a service done means a service paid (first off he didn't do it right so it's not even done) and that it doesn't matter how it was done, because that goes under his 'expenses' (as previously shown):
Gyazo - dfde6cd1dd1c8c7c660f827b8de7ead8.png
5)BECAUSE MARCELLUS WON'T SHOW IT HIMSELF, I get Anti to send me their messages together. Now he makes this accusation:
Gyazo - 6c2acb4351b5c3806be7a4eb3b4553e2.png
So he's helpful and honest, so we devised this plan ahead of time? Making these accusations are an indication of your guilt and not mine. To take them seriously, too? When Marcellus hasn't responded to anything I've said... c'mon lol.
6)I ask him direct questions, he deflects so that he doesn't accidentally self-incriminate himself:
Gyazo - 6e6f8c31de965c13cd16396c80b11344.png
7)I wasn't cheated at all! I got what I paid for! Except I didn't and you did not go about it the right way. My last statement, 'dude you're paying these guys 1/5 of what we agreed' ignore that because he pays them nothing!
Gyazo - 276415a2875ed5e899431499fa82673a.png