Gfx battle

Xjaa and *(un-named)
(to remove popularity)


Please give a reason or we dont count your vote

It's a tie BAHAHAHAAH

 

The second one =p, The fact its blended well and I like the lighting, the text could use some work and the right side is a bit plain tho...

 

i'm going to have to chose the lesser of two evils, the top one...

the bottom one has far too much bad use of negative space, the text on it is unfitting for the style of sig, and there is no real... anything in it, no story to tell or what.

The top one has terrible lighting, it too has bad negative space, just not as much of it. it's a little too chaotic, but the text does fit in with the sig. This one also has alot more depth then the first one.

Looking at the styles of sigs, i can tell which is xjaa's and which is the "unknown" person.

And from what I can see, Xjaa, you changed your mind as to not be such a hypocrit aye?

 

I wasnt a fan of the first one it just looked kinda choppy.

 

I'm pretty sure I know the other artist

I'm going to have to go with the second one. Apart from the negative space used I like it better. With the sort of pastel look on his face it sorta sets the mood for sadness along with the dark colours and the little lighting. The text is the only downer for me.

 

I like the second one because the first one's render is way too sharp but I don't like the text very much on the second one.

 

Sorry sUffer, i'm ganna have to go with xjaa. He doesn't have as much negative space as you, and the text matches better..

I would pick neither if I had the choice ;D

 

I voted top one. The last one was WAY to dark.

 

1st one is way better on so many levels
The lighting is so much less artificial.
Usage of the spritishrender is done a lot better.
The colors are more appealing.
Also the 2nd one horribly utilized negative space.

 

i chose the bottom one because i just like it overall better, besides the negative space. also.... why does the top one have tdd's like symbol thing in it?

 

because that one is TDD's lol notice he choose that one =P

 

-_- the symbol i use is a photoshop defualt shape...

 

ooo lol, well then i dont get why it's in that sig at all.

 

TDD didnt make the other sig >.<

 

bottom, i like darker sigs

 

I vote the top one, it is a lot better.
It has more advanced techniques, better lighting and the bottom one has too much negative space.

 

Top one, much better. I'm pretty sure it's from sUffer.

 

Everything isnt all about effects, so i voted the 2nd one, it has great composition, the eye is greatly pulled to the focal point(the face) the top one seems really messed has no flow and the composition is making it pull towards the text which you dont want.Gj both of you

 

Either you read my mind or were both thinking about different things

 

Bottom looks cooler (Is that a good reason?)


If I were to be more serious I would say the bottom one because:

It looks more well-blended, and the C4D is too obvious in the first one.

Kai? I should start doing this more