Rate This Sig Please, :)!

After listening to some peoples comments
on watching tutorials and such
i came up with this.



or



Which ones better?
Rate outta 10. ​

 

Great job on it, if you want a harsh rating 6.5/10. If you animated it 8/10.

 

Don't know much about sigs but looks like it took alot of time.
if not 10/10. Either way 10/10 lol

I am more into the kind of sigs you made for me though.
I guess its more 'cartoonish' ?

 

First one, why do the colours split in the middle? I like the effects around the render, but it's way too small and the effects should be spread out over the whole sig. The text is average and detracts from the focal a bit, try to bring it a bit closer to the main focal point.

Second one is a mess of colours and little to no flow, don't like the text either.

 

lol i like the monkey

 

nothing bland about it, nothing flashy, very laid back

 

i meant nothing too bland/ nothing too flashy