sig i think would be a 5/10 u need a bit more brushing and well it needs to have better font i think, orb is good but it needs a border overall about 6/10
The sig looks fair good (7.5) because it is simple yet giving the effect that is desired... The orb is quite bad, very bad quality, size and the way it is made is wrong.
Maybe look in the Signature and Sales sub-forum and se if anyone is doing Orbs for free or a low price.
first of all, you shouldn't be worrying about ratings, they mean nothing, it is the CnC you want. Second of all, that orb isn't crash hot, have you tried following some tutorials? The sig, it's very basic, and the text stands out too much, you don't want the text to be your focal, you want the focal to be the focal, if you get what i'm saying ;p but overall it's good for a beginner, it just lacks the OOMPH