Potential Market Manipulation

[Market Manipulation]

Link the current Sythe account:anamules420 | Sell & Trade Game Items | OSRS Gold | ELO (sythe.org)
Sire Emporium | Sell & Trade Game Items | OSRS Gold | ELO (sythe.org)
Which violation you are reporting the user for: Market manipulation
Why you think they're violating Sythe rules: When searching around to purchase AHK it seems like Anamules420 is a developer in Sire's discord selling the same product on both Sythe threads. I could be wrong and a simple screenshot of their agreement could clear this up

 

@anamules420 @Sire Emporium are the battle buddy scripts being sold in both servers?

 

Hello yoshiki apologies for the mistake that I have made. As of yesterday even before this post was made I have ceased any business with battlebuddy aio.

Imgur: The magic of the Internet -as seen here

imgur.com - this is evidence that I also removed anything related to pricing of the product.

 

I will agree I made a mistake on my end and I apologize. Let me know what I have to do to fix all of this.

 

@Yoshiki

 

ohh and one $30 subscription was sold for a $6 profit on my end. I'm willing to pay back whatever is needed to make this right.

 

i also stopped the auto bumper on the post yesterday
picture

 

@anamules420 care to comment?

 

[anamules420]

No buddy this is obviously a disgruntled competitor that's upset PurpScripts is successful. No scams have happened no price gouging has happened, I cant even find market manipulation in your TOS. Not sure why you are wasting our time on this matter. I have not manipulated or taken advantage of any customer. If we are guilty of anything its hustling business don't think that's against your rules, if you go look at the vouches next time you slide into the discord server and check our scythe vouches you will see no negative reviews or disgruntled customers. Unless you have proof our pricing is different, that we have gouged customers, lied, stolen, or been deceptive in our business dealings or that any violations have taken place what you can do is promptly close this as its a waste of time. Furthermore this alleged victim is claiming we sell the same products in our discord, I don't even sell products in my discord I sell on my website also any tickets that did come into sire emporium they were directed to my discord for business, no one tried to hide anything from anyone I don't see any rules in your TOS about having partners or hustling business. Would like this promptly closed as it gives my business a bad name and we don't scam anyone ever never gonna happen would appreciate it if you'd stop entertaining this nefarious way for competitor's to cause problems for other competitors.

 

No buddy this is obviously a disgruntled competitor that's upset PurpScripts is successful. No scams have happened no price gouging has happened, I cant even find market manipulation in your TOS. Not sure why you are wasting our time on this matter. I have not manipulated or taken advantage of any customer. If we are guilty of anything its hustling business don't think that's against your rules, if you go look at the vouches next time you slide into the discord server and check our scythe vouches you will see no negative reviews or disgruntled customers. Unless you have proof our pricing is different, that we have gouged customers, lied, stolen, or been deceptive in our business dealings or that any violations have taken place what you can do is promptly close this as its a waste of time. Furthermore this alleged victim is claiming we sell the same products in our discord, I don't even sell products in my discord I sell on my website also any tickets that did come into sire emporium they were directed to my discord for business, no one tried to hide anything from anyone I don't see any rules in your TOS about having partners or hustling business. Would like this promptly closed as it gives my business a bad name and we don't scam anyone ever never gonna happen would appreciate it if you'd stop entertaining this nefarious way for competitor's to cause problems for other competitors.

This is the rule you were breaking.

• Attempting To Bypass the 1 Thread per Market Section Limit: You may only have one thread per market section advertising your goods, services, or platform (Discord server/website, etc) unless otherwise specified. Attempts to circumvent this limit will result in a 1 month ban and possibly a DNT in severe cases.

 

[anamules420]

Subject: Clarification Regarding Alleged Rule Violation and Market Manipulation

Dear [Yoshiki],

I appreciate your prompt response and the opportunity to address the situation. I would like to provide further context regarding the alleged violation of the “Attempting To Bypass the 1 Thread per Market Section Limit” rule.

1. Understanding the Rule:
   • I acknowledge the importance of maintaining a fair and organized marketplace. The rule clearly states that each user is allowed only one thread per market section to advertise their goods, services, or platform.
   • I have diligently adhered to this rule by ensuring that our offerings are presented within the specified limits.
2. Our Compliance:
   • Our product, “Battle Buddy,” was never advertised on Sire Emporium’s Sythe post. We strictly adhered to the one-thread-per-market-section policy.
   • Furthermore, no Battle Buddy products were distributed via Sire Emporium Discord server. Our customer transcripts confirm this fact.
3. Market Manipulation Allegation:
   • The report alleges “market manipulation,” which is distinct from duplicate thread post violations. However, this violation is not explicitly listed in Sythe forum rules or your Terms of Service.
   • I urge you to consider the lack of clarity regarding this specific violation. Without clear guidelines, it becomes challenging for users to navigate the rules effectively.
4. Anonymous Reporting:
   • The account reporting us is a guest, and their anonymity raises concerns. Allowing users to hide their identity when making claims encourages repeated behavior without accountability.
   • Transparency is essential for maintaining a fair and just community. I recommend revisiting the policy on anonymous reporting.
5. Evidence and Retaliation:
   • I have attached files below that demonstrate Battle Buddy was not listed for sale in Sire Emporium. Additionally, the identity of the disgruntled competitor is evident.
   • This individual has been an ongoing issue, and we nearly banned them from our server a few months ago. Their report appears retaliatory due to competition.

Request:
I kindly request that you thoroughly review the evidence and reconsider the claim. Removing this false allegation will allow us to focus on providing quality services to the community.

Thank you for your attention, and I look forward to resolving this matter promptly.

Sincerely,

[PurpScripts]

Please see the below pictures for further evidence on who the competitor was that came into sire emporium discord as well as the sire emporiums ticket tool which clearly was not labeled to sell battle buddy in any way!

 

I acknowledge the importance of maintaining a fair and organized marketplace. The rule clearly states that each user is allowed only one thread per market section to advertise their goods, services, or platform.
I have diligently adhered to this rule by ensuring that our offerings are presented within the specified limits.

Your product was advertised in his discord server, his discord server is advertised on sythe. This circumvents the one thread per section rule.

Our Compliance:
Our product, “Battle Buddy,” was never advertised on Sire Emporium’s Sythe post. We strictly adhered to the one-thread-per-market-section policy.
Furthermore, no Battle Buddy products were distributed via Sire Emporium Discord server. Our customer transcripts confirm this fact.

I went into his server and there was an option to purchase it.

Market Manipulation Allegation:
The report alleges “market manipulation,” which is distinct from duplicate thread post violations. However, this violation is not explicitly listed in Sythe forum rules or your Terms of Service.
I urge you to consider the lack of clarity regarding this specific violation. Without clear guidelines, it becomes challenging for users to navigate the rules effectively.

The user reporting you is refering to the old name for the rule, I linked the rule you are breaking in a previous post.

Anonymous Reporting:
The account reporting us is a guest, and their anonymity raises concerns. Allowing users to hide their identity when making claims encourages repeated behavior without accountability.
Transparency is essential for maintaining a fair and just community. I recommend revisiting the policy on anonymous reporting.

People are allowed to report anonymously. We will not be changing this rule.

Evidence and Retaliation:
I have attached files below that demonstrate Battle Buddy was not listed for sale in Sire Emporium. Additionally, the identity of the disgruntled competitor is evident.
This individual has been an ongoing issue, and we nearly banned them from our server a few months ago. Their report appears retaliatory due to competition.

I have evidence that would contradict this. Retaliatory or not, you broke the rules.

anamules has been banned for one month for "Attempting To Bypass the 1 Thread per Market Section Limit".
Sire Emporium did not have two threads so he will not be punished.