Rate/Hate/Appriciate

Rate/Hate/Appriciate​

 

Iron man? 10/10...like it.

 

Ahh I like the first one best, although I don't really like the text.

 

lighting is backwards >_<

look at the highlights on the render and compare to the background

 

8/10, Great job

 

Yea, i'd say 8/10 right now. But if you clean up the text a little 8.5/10.

But overall, job well done!

 

Yeh the overall is good only the text is kind of to far on the side.

 

Lighting doesn't fit with the render, text isn't great, and you could use more depth.

What I like:

I like the colors, and the way you did the grunge effect.

 

Yeah, I think I'll rotate the bg so it fits better, I only noticed that when I finished.

Text was a bit rushed, I had to make it quick as an entry on a sotw on another site.

Yeah, I used gimp. I find gimp just as good as ps so I'm using it for now. If you want some help making that kind of bg on gimp I could send you some .xcfs of my work.

Yeah, Like I said above I didn't notice the lighting till it was to late. Most of what I did on that sig was quite random, I tried some different stuff and it turned out well.

 

Good job.
Work on your text.

 

I love it. I think it is totally awesome. Could you hit me up on MSN - [email protected]
I want to talk to you about something

 

Yeah, I didn't know what to do but I figuired that would do.

Ty, I added you on msn also.

 

the 2 Is Cool Nice =)

 

The overall sig is great. I just believe that the drop shadow on Iron Man is horrible and should have never been used.

 

Its isn't drop shadow, it's a duplicated layer blured set to burn. I fixed that along with bg and text and will be posting my updated version soon.

 

Text needs work like others said and i cant really say much else lol everyone else has said it all. Good job.

 

when you add the black cross lines, overlay the crossline layer to the background layer. looks way better. and try to blend the render abit so it fits better to bg. anyways, looks pretty decent. try those things I told and post the result here, I promise it wont look any worse

edit:

add 1px wide black frames to it. looks better, I swear and the text, center it more. looks bad when it's right in the corner, you can try to overlay that too..

 

Black crosses are on 50% opacity on normal and 1px borders are gai. I can't overlay because the layer under it is a 1px expanded alpha selection filled with white.

 

I really hate the text and you kinda whored the smudging and the black shadow thing behind the render is too uniform but it looks good!
7/10
By the way what's the difference between the 3 versions...?

 

Good job on the render and the colour of the background suits Iron man really well, it's just the text I'm worried use a much suitable one. and As of the 3 signatures I hate the second and the third one. Just keep it normal the first one it's better.