It mainly comes down to an act of good faith. You must have faith that the buyer will not charge back as well as taking the necessary precautions. For instance, have him send it as money owed or as a gift, because it's harder to win a "fraudulent access" dispute over an item dispute.
What most MM's do is they have a MMing PayPal linked with a pre-paid card with $0, so there is no money to be lost if something goes astray, or they simply won't handle the money. This is done via, they get the virtual item (GP) off you, the buyer sends the money to you (PayPal), the MM moves the virtual item (GP) to the buyer. So technically, that's a MM without touching the PayPal.