is this good for my first time, with no help?

well heres the image at now:





heres it before:




please rate it 1-10, i no it will be low. and comment please, thanks!

 

ive made another 1 that i like, wut u guys think??




heres a new 1, i think i messed the name up though :/

 

try not to post twice in a row its against the rules, but yeah dude that looks sick, i saw ur avvy in onther forum where u posted and iwas like: whoa! i give it a 6/10 though cause no real background or border u just changed the colors, but it looks good

 

its not half that bad...

 

thx guys. im guna try to make some more, using other stuff. the border i used messed up the image size so i got rid of it, if any1 has some requests i'll do it for free.

o ya, srry for double post.

 

Guys, i know im coming out of nowhere here.. But seriously give me a break.. It doesnt look alright.. Jackc, you should follow some tuts for gfx dude, cus srsly.. That is poor. If i had to rate i'd give a 1/10. You just need to know this. I hope you do get better though.

 

kk, anyways did you make that sig?

 

dude thats prty bad...its just a difference blending with some text that i cant read...2/10

 

Looks good for the first try with no help! I would like a sig anyone can make I want really cool looking colors ( Like hers ) but I want the main image to be a popgun lol. Pm me for more details I dont know just seen she would do it for free so I pulled this off of the top of my head. Looks good I give you 8/10 ( it was your first one )
Thanks
~ POPGUN ~