• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Illegally-Gained Giftcard's

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 12, 2017
Sythe Gold
32,813
Messages
77,836
Location
-⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐-
Vouch Thread
Click Here
Discord Unique ID
574588629343797257
Discord Username
Rpgstock
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Gohan has AIDS
Heidy
Potamus
Toast Wallet User
SytheSteamer
Nitro Booster
Dragon Claws
Two Factor Authentication User
Discord Verified
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Homosex
Lawrence
Can we get some clarifications on IF we can buy/sell illegally (e-whored/hacked/chargebacked) giftcard's?
I'm assume that it's bannable but I messaged a couple of mod's a week ago and they weren't sure.

Yes, I know that it's impossible to know if/when but It should be specified on the thread.
and Bryan, "Don't say report the post." Ty < 3


Should be updated: What can be sold/bought here?
 
Last edited:
It's probably banable but it is really hard to prove that they are illegally acquired and it's not like the seller is going to come forward themselves with incriminating evidence.
 
If selling hacked GP/buying hacked stolen gold is bannable I'd assume buying hacked/stolen giftcards would also fall under blackhat activity which is also bannable. However, it is very hard to differ between since the seller would obviously not come forward with how it has been acquired.
 
Last edited:
Physical gift cards strike me as the most legitimate source, as for the e-codes, there's simply no way to tell how the seller acquires them
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Extreme Homosex
Hoover
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Potamus
Physical gift cards strike me as the most legitimate source, as for the e-codes, there's simply no way to tell how the seller acquires them
This, there really can't be any rule that clarified the difference, you can definitely say knowingly buying a hacked card would be stupid and against the rules, but then again what seller is going to tell you that.
 
Its a don't ask don't tell situation.

Most giftcards(95%) that are stolen or e-whored never have any issues, its actually rare that their chargedbacked/reversed, most people don't ask where they came from, and most people don't tell.

To my knowledge knowingly SELLING cracked/stolen items is illegal, but I've never heard of anyone banned for BUYING them.

Typically most people who have brains are wise enough not to buy stolen things, the penalties for buying stolen things often bites you in the ass and that's punishment enough.

It has always been a grey area and probably always will be, I don't see how you could punish someone if someone tells them they e-whored the giftcard and they buy it to make a buck, they didn't e-whore it, they were just the ones with the "hot potato" at the end so to speak, and they take the risk of the card being recovered.

There's really a trade off with buying stolen things, yes you stand to profit more but at the same time your exposed to far more risk.

Selling is different than buying, selling stolen/hacked items is bannable under blackhat and scamming, buying though to my knowledge is case by case.

I have seen cases where its been argued like knowing ur buying a stolen gc associates u with blackhat and that's a ban but the cases always fall through.

It's my understanding that;

Selling blackhat/illegally obtained items/giftcards = Perm Ban for blackhat/scamming
Buying blackhat/illegaly obtained items/giftcards = No punishment

Especially now vs the past where blackhat is punished for far less and punishments are far less serious that I'd be surprised if buying a stolen item is considered illegal(even if ur told its stolen/e-whored).

It might be unethical but you weren't the one who stole it, your not the one liable for the theft or the e-whoring, but you run the risk of it being taken away if u get caught(chargedbacked/reversed in this case) a real life example of this is a pawn shop buying stolen items, some shady pawn shops will buy items regardless of where they come from, they don't get prosecuted for the thefts, they just get the item taken away from them. Unethical business practices shouldn't be encouraged but at the same time they are not always illegal.

It's one of those grey areas, I don't see any reason for Sythe staff to get involved if someone chooses to buy unethically obtained items, that's the risk the buyer takes when doing such a transaction.

Free Market.

I could be wrong.
 
Last edited:
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Extreme Homosex
Hoover
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Potamus
Its a don't ask don't tell situation.

Most giftcards(95%) that are stolen or e-whored never have any issues, its actually rare that their chargedbacked/reversed, most people don't ask where they came from, and most people don't tell.

To my knowledge knowingly SELLING cracked/stolen items is illegal, but I've never heard of anyone banned for BUYING them.

Typically most people who have brains are wise enough not to buy stolen things, the penalties for buying stolen things often bites you in the ass and that's punishment enough.

It has always been a grey area and probably always will be, I don't see how you could punish someone if someone tells them they e-whored the giftcard and they buy it to make a buck, they didn't e-whore it, they were just the ones with the "hot potato" at the end so to speak, and they take the risk of the card being recovered.

There's really a trade off with buying stolen things, yes you stand to profit more but at the same time your exposed to far more risk.

Selling is different than buying, selling stolen/hacked items is bannable under blackhat and scamming, buying though to my knowledge is case by case.

I have seen cases where its been argued like knowing ur buying a stolen gc associates u with blackhat and that's a ban but the cases always fall through.

It's my understanding that;

Selling blackhat/illegally obtained items/giftcards = Perm Ban for blackhat/scamming
Buying blackhat/illegaly obtained items/giftcards = No punishment

Especially now vs the past where blackhat is punished for far less and punishments are far less serious that I'd be surprised if buying a stolen item is considered illegal(even if ur told its stolen/e-whored).

It might be unethical but you weren't the one who stole it, your not the one liable for the theft or the e-whoring, but you run the risk of it being taken away if u get caught(chargedbacked/reversed in this case) a real life example of this is a pawn shop buying stolen items, some shady pawn shops will buy items regardless of where they come from, they don't get prosecuted for the thefts, they just get the item taken away from them. Unethical business practices shouldn't be encouraged but at the same time they are not always illegal.

It's one of those grey areas, I don't see any reason for Sythe staff to get involved if someone chooses to buy unethically obtained items, that's the risk the buyer takes when doing such a transaction.

Free Market.

I could be wrong.
Didn't someone just get banned for buying blackhat gp?
 
Nobody is going to know how a giftcard is obtained, so wtf is the point of this thread
Chicks was banned cause his "joking" was considered proof of the gold him buying being hacked, there is no concrete proof.
 
Discord Verified
Dragon Claws
Nitro Booster
Poképedia
I've asked this question to multiple staff members, and I was told that I should always get proof of purchase for giftcard, and if the seller claims it's not stolen and you purchase a stolen giftcard, you wouldn't be at fault because you didn't know you were purchasing something illegal.
 
I've asked this question to multiple staff members, and I was told that I should always get proof of purchase for giftcard, and if the seller claims it's not stolen and you purchase a stolen giftcard, you wouldn't be at fault because you didn't know you were purchasing something illegal.

Whichever staff told you that is wrong(or perhaps confused), ask an administrator on grey issues like this.

I'm not insulting the staff here, but this isn't the first time a greyhat stance has been mixed back and forth depending on the individual staff.

Its not the buyers responsibility to assure that something their buying is not stolen in this marketplace, that would be like if Bogla bought hacked GP and than sold it to his customers and the customers get banned on Sythe for buying hacked GP because they didn't ask if the gold was hacked. That responsibility lays on sellers not to sell those types of goods, that's a seller responsibility, not a buyers.

Not how it works lol, pretty sure the staff u asked were either confused or didn't understand what was being asked.

Which is why I said above;
It's my understanding that;

Selling blackhat/illegally obtained items/giftcards = Perm Ban for blackhat/scamming
Buying blackhat/illegaly obtained items/giftcards = No punishment
 
Last edited:
In Memory of Jon
Phanpy
Donphan
Rakashrug
Gooby
Detective
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Valentine's Day 2015
Halloween 2015
Christmas 2015
Easter 2016
Paper Trading Competition Participant
<3 n4n0
Verified Bronze
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
Nitro Booster
Verified Ironman
Poképedia
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Former OMM
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Extreme Homosex
If selling hacked GP/buying hacked stolen gold is bannable I'd assume buying hacked/stolen giftcards would also fall under blackhat activity which is also bannable. However, it is very hard to differ between since the seller would obviously not come forward with how it has been acquired.

This is the answer. Knowingly (key word here) buying/selling any product that has been hacked/stolen (gold, gp, accounts, etc.) is not allowed.

For your own benefit it is recommended that you ask a seller to provide proof of the legitimacy of their gift cards as a hacked/frauded gift card is much more likely to be reclaimed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top