@Epicdude
First I'm going to wait for an e-mail reply from PayPal and see what they have to say (should be getting in 1-2 days). If that doesn't work, I'm calling them and explaining the scenario and complaining to them until they do something.. And if that doesn't work I guess I have to resort to giving the PayPal to a trustworthy member.. I'm still cautious about that because I don't want anyone having my personal info, but hopefully it won't come to that.

