My first 2 sigs. Rate please :)

Okay so i put a few hours work in to these sigs. THE FIRST ONE MOSTLY.

Here they are


1. - w000t helped me.



2. - all by myself - Idk how to fix the lighting


3. - done all by myself and im very impressed =]


4. - My best one so far that was done by myself following a tutorial.

 

The first one is alright..
As for the second one, not do good.. Edges need smoothing out, Light source and vectors just random..
The first one, again, is pretty good though =]

 

Thanks so much. And for the second one. Idfk what happened. There was randomly lighting. I fixed so im gonna re-post.

 

Not bad for your first

First one seems reasonably nice, although the background seems far too empty even with all the shapes. Coloured background would look good I think. Also don't make your render/stock too small, I think it's just cutting the limits, but looks fine overall.

2 and 3 look quite simple, for the third I wouldn't blur the background like that in most cases, but totally up to you

Keep working at it!

 

It's hard to give an opinion on something made through a tutorial, but I can say try using colour schemes like that in your future work since it works well