First & Second Signature!

Hi guys, started photoshop today and made 2 signatures. If you guys could rate them, thanks! I am giving these away too if actually someone wants them. Haha

#1


#2

 

Very nice firsts.

I don't really like the color scheme in the Spiderman background kind of clashes with Spiderman IMO.

The Assassin's Creed one on the other hand looks great.

 

Pretty decent for first ones.
I presonally don't like any signature that has one base picture though.
But yeah, well everyone has their own taste. ^,^

 

There nice, but too basic.

 

This is constructive critisism, please don't take this as rude/disrespectful.
(I am also keeping in mind it's your first 2 sigs)

#1
The blending is actially not too bad, but the background is so flat behind him, it really fucks up the depth of it all, and makes for a kind of boring piece.

I'd recommend making alot more of the colors blend farther into the signature, watch/look at a bunch of smudging tutorials.

#2
The stocks seems very stretched horizontally, and it definitely shows.
I don't know if u planned it, but the light from the side versus the light against his robe are matched perfectly, adding for great depth in the piece

I'd recommend the same type thing, a little more background to render/stock blending as an image on a background with a little blur smudge doesn't make for an effectively smooth piece

All and all I'd give it 6.5/10 for your pieces, kudos.

 

Thanks for the feedback! Tried another one...

 

I really like this one- A lot better then the other two in my opinion.

I didn't like the colors in the first one but I did like the assassins creed one.

 

My comments still stand from before, the focus sticks way off the page like u just pasted him onto a background, try blending, A LOT more, like almost overkill til u get used to it, then find a happy medium.