Which account would you keep?

I have 2 skillers.

1) 83 Mining, 55 Smithing, 90 firemaking


2) 10 Mining, 96 (nearly 97) Fishing.



I have all the bots used in 1 such as AutoSmelter Pro, Kminer, Perfect Firemaker etc.

With this new email login, i want to keep one as my own personal account and sell the other. I personally think that number 2 has a much lower ban rate than 1, although im unsure of which one to keep.

If i were to keep 1, i would get 99 mining 99 firemaking and slowly growing smithing.

If i were to keep 2, i would get 99 Fishing 99 Mining and maybe then do Firemaking.

Which one would you keep and why?

Cash is no problem as i plan to do mining on both.

 

Account 1, I love Mining skillcape, and it's good money.

 

Account 1. Fishing isn't very good money and mining can be very profitable (Or so I'm told, how I am not sure. Rune ore I guess)

 

account 1 keep


acc 2 sell, not worth as much

 

account 1 all the way, seems you can have an easy two skills capes one right aftet the other. fishing is a bitch, yes you can make a good amount of cash but it takes so much longer

 

Better to keep account 2 imo, fish skill cape soon + lower ban rate. Mining 83 is not hard to do, 1-2 weeks and done.

 

Mining is very slow and he'll probably get more for selling account 2.

Fishing is not a very good skill to have high as the money making possibilities are very limited.

 

I'd keep account #2.
Not sure why, but I like it better.

 

Get 99's on both of them, and sell.

 

I'd personally do account 2. way cooler stats to have 99(H) and get fishing with sharks

 

The Poll is split. If i went for Account 2, does anyone know rocktail xp an hour and cash an hour?

Account 1 needs alot more work it seems.

 

Account 1 for sure. (I love minning and firemaking capes!)

 

Number two, much closer to a skillcape.

 

Added pictures. Sorry for poor quality.

 

Fish is less botted and the cape has nice colors to match things with.

 

Yes, i would say the Fisher has less chance of a ban. Infact, i would give it a 0% chance.

 

Having a skill cape is cool for the novelty, but at the end of the day, fishing is not even close to being the best skill for making money.

 

getting mining to 87 is really fast job , so u shoulda keep fisher what amounts of cash on accs?

 

Account one, if its still got the money from mining

 

13mil (dragon pick + cash) on 1
1.5 mil on 2

Yes it does.

I think i am swaying more towards 1 aswell. Rawrasaurus made a great point on money making. As with account 1, i can mine rune (with 45 dungeoneering) and make steel bars etc. So it is more of an "investment" than account 2.