Rate my MS Paint sig

Rate my MS paint sig. First ever attempt at a sig, and its in paint...

Rate 1-10 and give me tips on how to make it better.

Thanks

 

Uhh, no comment.

 

if you are going to make an MSPaint sig, you should at least learn how to dither and shade, do this buy selecting the color wih the eye dropper, then go ito the color change area, and slide it down a little bit so the color is slightly darker then the last one, then shade it where it wouldbe naturally shaded from the light source.

 

Umm...what does shading do lol.

 

adds depth

 

K thanks for your help

 

nice for first try its very hard to do...

 

7/10 good work.

 

It's better than I can do with Paint.. Meh, it's okay Keep trying!

 

Mehh its ok for first the only part that looks ok is the ice barrage

 

Good work! I would never be able to do that lol...

 

thanks for the feedback guys.

 

I'd give it a 2, but since it's a first try, I'll give a 3 out of 10.

 

no dithering or anything... just looks like you used a bucket and spray paint....
2/10

 

5 out of a 10.

 

No shading, it's really not good at all. Sorry.