I haven't played either of the both but i'd just stick to the original xbox 360 the new gen stuff is just overrated and way to expensive and not really worth the price in my opinion but if anything i'd go with the xbox 1
i prefer the playstation overall but its just a personal opinion this topic cant be too argued upon because we really cant come to a conclusion. The best conclusion is find how many more friends play on which counsel and whoever plays more on either one get that one!