60 attack barrows turmoil OR 80 attack zerker with turmoil OR 30 defence turmoil

Both are around the same combat, and don't ask me to see vids of them in action-I've seen them all. I want YOUR opinion. There are pros/cons for each of them, but I really want to see what you guys come up with. I want something that I can stick with. What I've come up with so far;

30 defence turmoil pure(85-90 attack)
-Gets spec'd out too often
+High accuracy, more weapons available
-Very few gear options, degradable armor is almost a must for pking because you get spec'd out too often without it, and that is just expensive

45 defence turmoil(75-80 attack)
+High/Medium accuracy, more weapons available
-Moderate level gear options
-Can easily get combo'd and wrecked by a main with low defence
-sucks at hybriding (gets hit too often+mage bonus is too low+splashy)
-CAN'T TANK A TB (lol, how I lost bank )

75 defence turmoil (60 attack)
-Low accuracy, very few weapon choices
+Huge range of equipment available
+Can hybrid decently without getting hit too often
+Doesn't get spec'd out too often
-can easily hit 0's even on 40 defence rune
+Can tank
-The only overpowered spec weapon is Dragon Claws (compared to AGS to the above choices)

What's your opinion? State why you think so, too.
Appreciate it

 

Get thirty defence with sixty attack and go hybrid the 80s.

 

Most likely going to be stuck with low hp/str if I do hybrid them in the 80's. 60 attack 99 str 30 defence turmoil is around 93-94 cb