Mr. Pencil's Ban Dispute

It all started when this dude asked me to do a cape for him so i agreed, he payed cash and claimed and cancel. He told me i got 11 hrs to do the cape. So i told him i'd finish it in the morning. He then logs on the acc b4 i do after he said he wouldnt unless i pm and tell him it's ok. He dies in the cave and i tell him im not redoing or refunding because he broke the agreement. I offer for him to get back where i was an ill do it so he says iite.So then after a few hrs he says that if i buy some junk from him he'll forget about the cape. So i bought his maple longs (u) and he files a claim on paypal again for his cash back. Grave (the goldseller) was helping me with telling me what to do during the claim. He was helping and he can vouch that this dude is a scammer.

If u need to make a decision to bann me then talk to Grave first plz

http://i44.tinypic.com/24xmo3s.jpg
http://i43.tinypic.com/167wbol.jpg


http://i42.tinypic.com/1zyg6s9.jpg

So now i ask myself is it right for me to get banned if the dude made an agreement with me that if i buy his junk he'd forget about the cape so i did and he claims back the cash so i screw up his pure. IF YOU LOOK ON MY FIRECAPE THREAD YOU CAN EVEN SEE THAT IF YOU LOG INTO THE ACC WHILE IM IN THE CAVES AND YOU DIE, YOU WILL NOT GET A REFUND NOR WILL I REDO!

MY FIRECAPE THREAD WITH THE AGREEMENT:

http://sythe.org/showthread.php?t=633198

 

I've talked to grave with this and I sorted it out with him, You will be unbanned. The other user will be banned for breaking the agreement and claiming back the money.

EDIT:

http://sythe.org/showthread.php?t=635105&highlight=pencil

The msn chatlogs show you deliberately messing up his account (I believe he had some sort of pure with 1 defence) and screwing him over by changing the recoveries and locking the account. This alone is categorized as scamming. I can have another global or admin look at it but the whole trade was sketchy in the first place. You should not have offered to do it again after he had logged in, and you buying his junk in exchange was a mistake on your part. Then you commence to ruin his pure by messing with his stats because he would not give you back the money. On both parts, I think both of you should be banned.

 

His disputes have been denied lots of times.
No.
Denied.