[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v234/sTr1kEr/Untitled-3-5.jpg[/IMG]

Eh.

v2:

I like v2. This is where I was going to stop but decided to keep going anyway :\

 

This would be truly epic if the light source werent so srtong and the colors, werent so light.

Good job overall.
And it almost looks like it was made from a render

 

mhmm....

.
.
..
....
......
Ther's alot of pixelation that doesn't look that good nor does it flow. The space on the far left is really bad for how the sig is set out. If your going to do alot of colors, do NOT sharpen the colors on the brushes that much, even though the colors don't look nice mixed like that.

The lighting and render placement fits very nice. The blending through the layers it alright but with those colors it decreases the blending and flow. Text fits good and so does the orange squares (nice touch) but the little text underneath is bad.

Ive seen better from you MD, like your current sig. Although a good GFXer needs to try lots of syle to know what you can and should mix etc.

Better luck next time 6.8/10

 

Good feedback.
Although on one part, you say don't sharpen brushes, it isn't brushing

And yes, xjaa, the whole sig was based off of stocks, 4 or 5 different ones not including the actual render :d
But yeah I just wanted to try somethin diff.

v2:

I like v2. This is where I was going to stop but decided to keep going anyway :\

 

v2:

I like v2. This is where I was going to stop but decided to keep going anyway :\

 

Yeah just looking at the backdrop in colors it would have had to be a pretty distorted stock in the first-place had it been only one
Good Job.

 

wow sexy but way to brite for me =\

 

Lol, my bad.

If V2 didn't have the mixed colors down the bottom and not toooo sharpened it would be fair nice...

I would give better feedback like before but Im playing UT 2004 atm. I might give more details if I feel like it

EDIT: and thnx for taking ym advice on the sharpening for V1... looks much better and now I would say its a 9/10 I luv it

 

i think version one is much better than the second one as there more color and less pixelation i think ur first ones great! keep up the good work

 

Personally I liked v1.

v2 looks far too washed out. I <3 the mini-squares in v1! Maybe draw them out a little and keep the contrasted effects of v2?

 

Hmm, i don't like it.

I never think it looks good to blur, or lay effects OVER the focal. It just makes it seam very unprofessional and messy.

I like the text on the top one, a lot more than the bottom one.

The problem with these is they're not clear. They ate very faded and blurry. That does not make a good sig IMO.

 

I like the first one a lot better. The second one not as good

rate 1:
8/10

rate 2:
6/10

good job dude.

 

I reckon a big thanks to you guys for the feedback <3
I was tryin some new shit, it turned out better than I expected but not as good as I wanted. Ah well, will post a new sig again someday.

 

both are pretty...good..
I like the first one in my opinion
nice sigs