Faster Fishing Xp?

I have a clue scroll in the fishing guild and I only have 60 fishing. What would be faster to get to 63, fishing lobsters at catherby, fishing swords/tuna at catherby, or fishing trout/salmon at shilo?

Thanks,
Rs Emperor

 

I'd probally do salmon & trout at Shilo.

 

Yeah fishing trout and salmon at shilo is the best exp in the game. So go there. Btw you need 68 fishing to get into the fishing guild. Goodluck though.

 

I'm going to start trout/salmon now and with 63 and an admiral pie, I can get into the Fishing Guild.

 

Fly fish at barb outpost (fastest fish xp in game)
it is about 5k faster than shilo and doesn't require any quests done
beleive me I did from 90 to 99 fishing

 

I would say they are about the same. I've done both and they both are approximately the same. Only difference is with shilo you can bank the fish.