Rate the sigs

I updated and tweaked both of my sigs [pay no attention to the text in the middle of the 2 sigs]

 

i liek spiderman one

 

thanks, anymore feedback?

 

They look awsome..The spiderman one looks likes he's in an alleyway..Nice

 

I like the first one=)

 

Is that with the photo shop? I gatta learn how to use it =p

 

I don't like the spider man one, doesn't match at all. It somewhat has a flow, but the render just doesn't blend. It might be better with a different render. I also hate the text it just doesn't fit. I like the halo one though.

 

is the first one halo? looks like masterchief with a gasmask

2nd one is the best just a little to tall so 6/10 and 7/10

 

they're both pretty good, althoug i do like halo one better, in the spiderman one it just seems like there a bit too much going on.
8/10 for halo
7.9/10 spiderman