[SFA]Reported Post by Xier0

[Xier0]

Xier0 has reported a post.

Reason:

This section has very strict rules compared to other forums. You WILL be banned from posting here if you fail to follow these continually.

• Only properly thought out, rational arguments are allowed in this forum
  
  We don't care if you LIKE Bush or THINK Global warming is man made.
  For example, in the thread "Is God real?"; "I think God is real" would be unacceptable whereas "I think God is not real because X research suggests Y therefore Z" would be acceptable.​
• Use, to the best of your ability, proper grammar and correct spelling
• Do not respond to spam posts, simply report them using the triangle on the top right of said post
• God arguments will be removed unless the original post contains a reasoned argument

"It's in the quran" is not a reasoned argument.

Post: Trump's proposal for Temp Muslim Ban
Forum: Something For All
Assigned Moderators: Blupig, Blade, Apith, Time To Buy, SellerMan

Posted by: Ghast
Original Content:

It is a necessary part of your claim that there is a god in order for Muhammad to be a prophet of god.

No it's not. It's documented within the Quran that Muhammad is a prophet, to which you've conformed to already on this thread.

Islamic law is the law that comes from the Islamic prophet, who issues commands for the Islamic god.

No you haven't. You just say you have and skip over it. The BURDEN OF PROOF LIES ON YOU AND I WILL NOT ACCEPT YOUR CLAIMS UNTIL YOU SATISFY YOUR BURDEN OF PROOF:

Already gave proof. http://www.questionsaboutislam.com/history-of-islam/who-is-mohammad.php

You made the claim "They cannot be both".

You must prove your claim that a thing cannot be religion if it is law, and cannot be law if it is religion.

Religion deals with the worship of a superhuman controlling power or God(s). Religion has nothing to do with worshiping laws, hence why laws can't be a religion, and vice versa.

Law consists of the established and enforced rules and regulations for keeping a community in order.

Religion is a personal belief system that incorporates philosophy, dogma, and ritualized ceremonies.

Law can't be religion, and religion can't be law for these reasons.

Law tells you what you must not do within the confines of communication between people. Religion isn't a person, it's a belief system.

 

[S]

I ain't deleting any posts between you and Ghast.