What Do You Think About The U.S Marine Throwing The Cute Puppy Off The Cliff

Yes it is, it is a new commercial for the army. Sarcasm

 

I found an answer to all of Shredderbeam's questions above. Unfortunately, he hasn't responded.

Have I won a debate against Shredderbeam? Not yet. =[
-Come on Shredder, I'm waiting for you.

And as stated in the beginning, this Thread was going to create a lot of Spam.
-2nd Page - "sick and gross"

Apparently.

 

Right. Some things simply are, devoid of any morality. You might as well ask: Is a rock moral?

I was arguing moral rights for humans, as rational beings deserve rights.

I cannot fathom how anybody would get upset over it. It's a puppy. It's not a person with a family, it didn't have hopes or dreams, it couldn't even comprehend the notion of rights.

I'd be upset, of course, as anybody would if their property was thrown off a cliff.

If you accept Kant's argument, then yes, that is correct.

We can rationally and sincerely will for somebody to treat a dog as property, yes.

Unjustified assumption. You need to demonstrate why they have these rights.

What is rational is that he has the right to treat property in any way that he wishes.

Let me copy that paragraph, but replace "animal" with "sofa":

"We can't, once again. The sofa has limited ways to defend itself. The marine is vastly overpowered in comparison. How is it rational to harm something that has done you little to no harm and has very little potential to do so? The act cannot be rational, so under Kant, it cannot be moral."

You're presuming that the puppy actually has a right to life. This is the underlying flaw in your argument.

No.

It's not wrong.

It's real.

If that's the worst thing that you have ever seen, then you must not have seen a lot:







But no, I'm sure that the poor, sad little puppy is worth fretting about.

I'm speaking of objective morality, not what most people think morality is.

 

I've seen that picture on a magazine 7years ago.

Once again it is really lame to do such things.

 

Haha Yeah Well I Have 3 Dogs Try Throwing one off a cliff and see what happends

 

Sorry But this is real It's already been leeked all around america and all over the news

 

Thanks, chief. Your valid, helpful contribution to this thread is valued.

 

I think this is better suited for SFA.

 

That was funny.

 

My mom is a dog breeder (13 dogs) and for a human being to even think of harming a dog of any sort. They must be pretty messed up in the head. RIP poor little dog..

 

My class talked about it. That's sick.

 

he might give his life so we can live freely, who cares about the puppy.

 

Wow how could you even do that to a puppy that guy has no respect for life.... even if it is just a puppy

 

You wash your hands.
"Dude, you have no respect for life.... even if it is just bacteria"
Why does a puppy deserve more rights than a bacteria? Would I do this to a puppy - no, but only because of my personal opinion. Who are you to judge other peoples' decisions and feelings towards animals?

 

That Fucking Sickens me I hope that man realizes what he has done is wrong and will one day suffer the consequences

 

That shit's whack.
I'd rather shoot heroin than do that to a puppy. And I'm a drug-free person.

 

well..
if it was just a regular guy i would have been pissed but a marine he defends our nation so heck i guess i can let him pass... the video graphic and sick.

 

I admit that was bad, but you are not a marine. Being a marine is much harder than any other branch of the military, people don't know what it's like i don't. So i think you should all shut the fuck up about this video he was in the wrong. But not all marines are like that. Become a marine or don't judge them.

 

The picture of the girl almost made me cry. I havn't cried in years that is the worst thing i have ever seen.

 

wtf not to kill as a species what about the dam cows getin eatin?????