Unholyfaith Scammer me out of over $100!

I posted I thread about wanting to buy neopets accounts. Unholyfaith was the only one who responded (see PM screenshots below). He added me on msn. Sent me screenshot of the neopets account as proof (image he sent is posted below along with full MSN convo). I sent him payment via paypal (see proof below). At first he wanted me to send a payment as a gift. I did not do this since you cannot dispute paypal gifts. So I sent it as goods. He then claimed he had to call paypal. After that he never responded again.

Also, the username of the neopets account he was offering for sale is edward_cricket which leads me to believe he may be associated with the [email protected] address which is the email of a well known scammer here on sythe (there have been multiple banned scammer account using that email here. I discovered this by doing a simply search).

Here are all the screenshots:

 

Insufficient as entire convo isn't shown, the trade could have continued later on.