Is my new sig good?:b

What would you rate my sig out of 10 and why, just wondering :b

 

3

But I am tired of seeing 3D sigs, and the colors and effects aren't done very well.

 

Tbh, I reckon mines better than yours.

 

I think it's pretty smart 8/10. The border to the text looks a bit out but still looks gooooooooooood!

 

lol

You asked people to be honest, I can pick it apart and tell you exactly what is wrong.

-It is boring, there are no effects and the only thing in the background is a little lighting effect
-The spacing between the letters is off and it is causing the borders to protrude into the other letters
-The colors don't mesh; gray and bright red doesn't go together, check a color wheel
-The depth of the text for the small text makes it look really bad because it makes the text more difficult to read then it needs to be
-You put no thought or creativity into doing it

 

I can read it perfect, and I didn't make it so yeh.

 

it looks okay, but whoever did it could have done a better job on it

 

'TheLuckyNub' looks alright, it's the bottom row that's a little difficult to read.

 

Seems too dark and the bottom text is a little hard to read. Also learn to take criticism if you're asking for it, not that it matters since you didn't even make it..

 

Boring. Need something original. Everyone has 3D with a grungy feel to it... same colors, as well.

 

5 out of 10.
The colours are very dull, it looks a bit cut off and it's not too fantastic overall.
The maker of this must be starting with Cinema4D I guess, as he forgot about a few very important points.
Anywhom:
I really miss some lightning, the flare (I guess..) on the background is being cut off by the text, if it would've gotten over the text a bit it would've looked alot better.
It's just not that good, simple as that.
Colours aren't nice looking, it's very dark, it looks pretty dull and overall it's not worth higher then a 6, as most people here know how 10/10 signatures would look like.

 

5/10

I feel the email is miss-placed in proportion to the picture.
should of placed the email somewhere else imo.
and the letters could of been done a bit better.

 

7/10, email out of wack imho.

 

I would hate to say it but: 4/10

1. The 3D text would only work with the large characters, not the small.
2. The colors don't blend well.
3. It's messy.
4. The effects are done horribly (it's cut-off...).

It's a bit of repetition from Emperor_Nero's but hopefully repetition of your mistakes will allow you to realize it's actually a mistake.

This is truly insulting to say this to one of the people who's giving you feedback on your signature. Use your head before using your heart, think about what critiques have told you before rampaging and getting angry because they said they don't like it.

 

i like it 7.5/10