Vouches from Banned Members

I think that vouches from people that have been banned should not count. Lets hear what you all think.

Supporters:
Belumoth

Against:
scottayy
blade bro4
Tckr

 

I don't support. For people that have a ton of vouches it would be such a hassle to go back and re number and re order all of the vouches. Plus the fact that they were vouched shows that the user trusted the person enough to think that they deserved a vouch before they were banned. Regardless of the user being banned or not it still shows that they were trusted at some point. Plus it is people's own decision to decide what is a quality vouch and what is not, I would rather have a vouch from a banned ex-admin than a free vouch that cost me nothing. You have to be able to determine on your own what is and what is not a quality vouch.

 

100% against this suggestion.
Most of the people here end up banned.
A legit trade is a legit trade, it doesn't matter what they do afterwards.

 

They should still count or peoples vouch counts would go down a lot.

 

yeah i understand that it would be a pain. idk just a though i had. cuz obviously the person that vouched you has lost all the trust that was given to them.

 

No sorry. You're telling me that if a user bought 1B from me legit, I shouldn't count it in my vouches/trading history? No support at all.

 

No, this is not a good idea at all, you still completed the trade successfully at the time, regardless if the person is banned or not.

 

No support.

A vouch is that; a confirmation of something taking place, in most cases a successful trade.

You may argue all you want that because someone is banned, their credibility is undermined, and thus the vouches. This is not the case. Whatever you say, the fact is a successful trade has taken place, and that can take place with the worst or best of man kind, and you cannot, and should not take that away from someone.

 

haha ok i have been out voted =P

you can close this if you want

 

Why?

I don't see any reason they shouldn't. A successful trade = a successful trade.

Against.

 

Why?

No support what so ever, if it was a successful trade when it happened, why should the vouch not be considered if the other trader got banned for doing something not concerning you. Also it'll be a major hassle for everyone with heaps of vouches to just go and delete them all especially because many people are getting banned quite frequently here on Sythe.

 

I give no support. If they go first to me and I get what I'm supposed to and our trade goes well then they scam or whatever doesn't mean it's still not a vouch. I look at vouch quality, money involved and such.

 

Don't support unless they were banned for fake vouching.

 

100% agreed. Not supported.

 

Yeh, i'm not bangin with you here, either. The legitimacy of a vouch is still the same even if the user is banned afterward.

 

Not happening for obvious reasons