I believe Finn's made an incorrect decision..

Harped made trolling, ban evading accounts.

 

So did Atomic.

 

Atomic's accounts were harmless, and it was obvious who he was.

Also, I believe he hacked a few MSNs.

 

So were Harped's.

There was never any proof he hacked any MSNs; he was pinned as a target because he frequently trolled. I'm not here to debate any pardons. I just think they should be discussed by more than one admin and scrutinized further.

 

He has admitted (to me at least) to hacking msns, faking proof, faking screenshots, etc...

 

Did you just get proven wrong?

 

PM me this "proof".

Not by your pathetic excuse for an argument, no.

 

I would, but I'm sure your response will be "that's not his msn" or something of that sort.

Why not reread his "farewell" if you've forgotten: http://www.sythe.org/showthread.php?t=801160

 

I don't think you're entitled to see any proof, now that you're not a staff member.

Oh and your argument is indeed so much better, should we unban Wow is Fun Fun while we're at it? I mean all he did was fake a couple of screenshots, but that's not as bad as phishing? Right? Because we haven't been given brains to assess a user's character traits before deciding on whether to unban him or not.

 

Everyone should drop the subject. Only time will tell if hes changed or not.

 

Looks like you didn't interpret my post correctly. Allow me to dumb this down for you.

I do not support the unban. I was simply using Harped as an example. There should be some consistency amongst pardons (maybe an admin consensus). Views can be easily skewed.

 

Note, case by case basis.

 

I am aware how it is currently being handled; my post was merely a suggestion.

 

Fair enough.

 

Have you not spoken with Atomic since? He is a great guy and seems to have changed alot. Give him a chance.

 

What?!?

I'll never get pardoned but others get it no problem, and all I did was troll a bit.

Itz Cfrey

 

Did you make a dispute bro?

 

I'm glad the staff has decided to bring Atomic back. By reading his appeal, I can tell he's changed, and he has a lot to contribute.

 

Yeah, I'm glad to see him back too. It's kind of strange to see so many people go recently, but then we have a lot of people come back a short while after. Atomic's pardon was earned, I think he's matured and now knows what's up. It was a fantastic choice by Finn to be honest.

Oh well, welcome back Atomic! You were missed.

 

This thread is not a debate over the legitimacy of his pardon or any other pardons denied or permitted. >_>