Help me decide something...

The outcome will really depend on how much effort you want to put into it, and whether you can get people to actually post reports on your site. Presumably, members will first report the user on the forums they added them from. If the user gets banned, or your template is too different, they may not bother with the additional report on your site.

I'm also curious, would chat logs be allowed?

 

I support. It would be a nice way to be a little bit more secure when doing a trade.

 

Yes, (sorry for late reply, been searching for thread for a while). While they may not be seen as valid proof, they'll still be allowed.

I also decided to add a comment part to each report, so people will be able to discuss the different posts, and rebuttal them publicly. I'm working on this site again, and will be looking for people to volunteer their time going through old Sythe scam reports and posting them on the site, momentarily. Have to finish it all up though.