Which account should i make P2P?

Ok so heres the short story:
I have my first runescape account that i have spent hours and hours trying to make it better, then i have this new account that i just got for doing some training.
Here is MY personal main account's stats:
Attack:43 Strength:56 Defence:45 Range:43 Prayer:35 Magic:41 R-Crafting:50 Health:50 Crafting:31 Mining:65 Smithing:55 Fishing:30 Cooking:41 F-Making:51 W-Cutting:54
NO MEMBER STATS!
Bank contents:
510k gold, full rune armour, Full range armour, Plenty of law and elemental runes 4 teleports, all f2p mage element staves, non-tradeable holiday and random event items, plenty of ores.
*all f2p quests are done, and the lumby/draynor diary is finished 100%.

Here are my NEW ACCOUNTS STATS:
attack:50 Strength:61 Defence:45 Range:72 Mage:42 R-Crafting:34 health:64 Agility:35 Theft:19 Crafting:61 Fletching:38 Slayer:28 mining:55ish Smithing:3 Fishing:55 cooking:45 Woodcutting:68 F-Making:33 *ALL OTHER STATS ARE 1*
*not all quests done, no diary lvls finished
Bank: In short, it came with minimal items, and only a few, idk what, members items. in 2 days, ive made around 300k and bought ranging equip.

So which should go be P2P?
Account 1 is ahead in more skills, and way ahead in questing, while...
Account 2 is obviously much more combatically strong, however has lower skiller lvls, and has only a few f2p quests done.
Thank you guys for leaving your opinion, please check out the bottom link in my signature if u have some advice for when i become a P2P
PS, please pm me if you know how to add images in a thread?

 

I'd say stick with the 1st one.

 

Whichever one you think is more fun? They are both pretty weak, so not much difference.

 

The first one, and make it into a main.

 

Probably the first account. You can get that 65 mining to 70 easily with the coal trucks, beats the hell out of the mining guild

 

Go with the the first account. CB related skills are very easy to gain in P2P. Your first account is better financially and skill wise compared to the second account. As well, the second account's P2P skills are relatively low. Meaning, you can get those levels within 2-3 days of efficient training.

 

the first one is your best bet.

 

the second one would be better

 

Ok, now say what if i got the second account to lv 65ish mining, and around 50ish smithing.

 

good

 

first one, unless u like to skill and quest and would do that on the second one

 

please dont spam the thread with "good". its an either or thread, hence, you must make a decision

 

id go with first one, since you created it you dont ever have to worry about it being recovered etc...

 

Exactly what i was going to say.

Don't take risks when there's not much difference.

Stick with #1.

 

just to throw it out there, the new account has never has email, recovs, or bank pins, and only 1 password.