Two new Sigs =) Rate/Hate...

Hey, I just made two sigs for another forum.
User is ♫iLLUSiON♪. They are basic, just getting the hang of Photoshop.

Don't really like the first one...


The second is my fav.


Do you like them, hate them please tell me, constructive criticism is welcome :laugh:
~ RS Assassin

 

Background on the first one is nice, i like it. You just need to work on your text. It would help the signature alot if you place the text in the middle and adding some more effects to it. Maybe to just drop a shadow. Just another tip is never use Bevel and Emboss on just text signatures.

Ok, on the second one, the reflection is nice. But you need to change the colour at the bottom of the signature. It's just too bright and puts down the whole signature.

 

They look good. I like the color choice for the first one. Like the poster above me explained, just work on your backgrounds, and you should be fine.

 

The second one is great. Has a great colour scheme etc. It also looks alot more smooth and less choppy. The first one sucks in my opinion, opposite of what I just said.