Evon VS. Ryaxxx: Duel to the Death

Evon VS. Ryaxxx - Duel to the Death!


Evon challenged me to a signature competition with the theme "Hitman". We were both assigned the same Hitman image.

Post why you voted.

We can't let you know who's who.

Here they are:

1.

2.

 

what is this all about

 

What? Can you like not read or something?

It's that easy.

 

#2 is better.


I have edited out your "spoiler" for the respect of the people in the gfx battle. There is a reason they posted this as anonymous, and I'm sure they would like to keep it that way - Bbri06

 

Thank you for influencing the weak minded, Sinful Thoughtz.

I voted for number two. The first has more thought put into the design, I believe, but is overall inferior. I see what you were trying to do, but I don't think you pulled it off well enough to out due #2.

 

I also vote number 2. I don't like the bevel, but the stock placement is better. With number one, the text let it down in my opinion.

 

1 is much better, there both not the best but number really does show more skill, the text on both is not used well.

The render does not fit in into the background imo.

For both.

 

2 is better...
the posioning of the text and the render is better than 1 and the background also made me choose 2.

 

I vote for #1.

On the second one the text is not very good, and the background is too simple. It needs some brushing, or something to make it smoother and go together.

 

The bevel is a turn off.

 

I like #2 more. Better blending and render placement in my opinion.

 

I voted for numero 2. It's more catchy, to me. I dislike the text placement in #1. Also the odd number stranded below kind of confuses me..

But, all in all, number 2 for teh win.

 

Number two looks better, simple.

 

Personally i think the second one is my favorite, The render is better placed, it's got better flow and blending, it's overall better.

 

number 2 is the best one by far...the first one is good and...but the 2nd one is better

 

47 is his agent number.

 

I voted 2, but some tips for both of you:

1. Try blend you render into the bg or let the spring out of the sig, not just copy onto a bg...
2. Make a better bg, this just lloks like it has come off google, copied it, and put some things on.
3. Also for the text, Do something more with it! The text always make the sig that more better if it has nice effects!
4. Always make a border! Just a 1 pixel black line is enough, but it just make it more professional
(5. This is only for sig number 2: Dont use that border, with the black&white, i forgot the name of it, but just dont use it)

That was all, an overall:

1. 4.5/10
2. 5.5/10

Greetz,
Zeboss