My New Sig

Ok so I haven't used photoshop in over three months now and wanted to see if I could still make sigs. Anyways please give me some advice?

 

I think the general idea of your sig is good. But the background of it is very fuzzy with white edges. You should polish up the details and then see what you can do. The edges need to be blended with the black. It really should be tidied up a lot.

 

Thanks I was thinking the same thing after I put out that result. I'll start working on that. Glad to have your constructive criticism

 

well i posted a new version of it

 

Background doesnt look good.. but 5/10

 

Asked for advice on how to make better didn't ask for a rate

 

That looks bad..
Bad backround and he character doesn't need to be "EMBOSSED"
You should have made a nice backround, and just maybe made a glow around the character.
Same with text...
2/10

 

You've used far too much bevel/emboss there. Cool that down a littleAlso, you should remove the inner glow you've used on some sections.I'm not gonna rate it. I don't rate stuff.

 

I think it's good other then the background and just dont emboss so much

 

I hate the emboss and the character and text looks faded out...

 

well once again changed it using peoples advice here was the original finish, but then added the purple in ms paint not sure if the original was better than the ms pain edited one

 

It's pretty good. The background is not bad. I personally would like to see a copy without the body being so smudged and maybe add more "stuff" to the background. There's a lot of "free space".

 

I think that you should give more emphasis on the character itself. Make it a different color than black because there is not enough emphasis on the character. Also, as said before, use that free space to the left for your name. Don't make it so small, fill in the free space. Finally, work on refining the details of your lines. Make them a little crisper and sharper.

 

plain, lacks with effects. try to blen the render a bit more. the smudgy edges doesn't look that good :S

 

Bad back ground and you over worked the render, try looking at some tuts and learn how to make a good bg and learn to make the render blend with the bg but make sure its still the main focal point. Also make sure you save it as .png so it comes out better and so some parts arnt pixely.

 

Not interested in anything you say. Shouldn't of wasted your time typing for I'm not going to waste my time reading it.....Come to think of it I just wasted my time typing this

anyways.

For everyone else who posted after I put up the latest version (hm0ng and Light) I will take your suggestions in and start working on it some more.

 

Anyways new form of the sig I have many versions of it
I think this is the best one character wise.

Also, Me Like Pies, sorry for being so rude earlier I just disliked something you posted on another thread
so I decided to ignore your post. After reading your post I would like to thank you for your advice I actually
used it in making this new form of the sig.

 

The background is a little sloppy with the figures. The idea of giving them two different colors is a good one, but the background turned a little sloppy. Also, i think that the one on the right (green) could use more detail in color (color eyes, hat, something differently.) But i think it is a lot better than the first time.

 

the new on looks better. tho it's not a good idea to make the renders so blended with the BH. and the different colours looks like a puke :S the text needs th "thing" and you could work a bit with teh ligh source.

 

Newest version made it blend less with the background like Light and Ridah said also gave the characters a bit more color. Changed background as well since it was kind of sloppy