Rate and discuss my new signature

I spent about thirty minutes on it, it's not great but I'm pleased with how it turned out. I'd appreciate it if you rated it from one to ten and commented on improvements and what you like.

 

make it smaller and maybe a gif.... u could have thunder in it atm 5/10

 

What the heck are you talking about? Why should I make it a gif if it's fine as a png? And what do you mean "u could have thunder in it atm"? Also, what are you basing 5/10 on?

 

Don't be mad, You said rate. it's his opinion.
Btw I Like it.
I Can see a little part of the sign in the inner part of the S.
7/10

 

I wasn't upset that he gave it a 5/10, I was upset that he can't put his feelings into actual words. Thanks, I tried to get rid of that, but was unable to keep the ace unchanged. Thanks for your comments.

 

Needs to be smaller, text sucks, text reflection sucks.

 

That, and it just looks like a C4D or just some brushes with a blue over it and the text shouldn't ever be stretched out in a reflection :3

 

simple, kinda nothing on it, sythe.org text looks stupid and it's boring.

5/10

 

Yer dont stretch the text, work on the reflection, get rid of the part of the sign that shows on the inside of the S and maybe make it a little smaller and it could possibly look a little better without the sythe.org text.
Also draggin .gif's usually come out alot shitter then a .png.

 

i like it

 

I think I've got it now. I'll make the format 550x300 again but I'll only do the top half and leave about 150 pixels on each side of it blank. Then I'll flatten and duplicate it, mirror it vertically, and skew it to each corner. That way it'll come out the way I wanted it originally, as if you were looking into a box with a "mirror" on the bottom. I kind of just started GFX so this is good practice, thanks for your suggestions guys!

 

Why make it so big? Why not keep it between 400×150.

 

I'd rate it a 4/10.
I personally think its too large.
I also think the text is boring and the shadows too dark.
Thats just my personal opinion,