My third photoshop sig (Silkroad Online)

Yup, I just made another sig today. I think it's cool.
Please rate it, and give some nice comments or some (constructive) criticism.



just added a pixelwide border....



dunno if its better now, but please, tell me what kind of border I should use, or maybe no border at all

EDIT:
UPDATED:


UPDATED AGAIN:
Now with a different twist I didn't chance the updated one, but the older one.
Does anybody what colour would look good as a border, I have no idea!


UPDATED AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAAAAAIN XD


This one is much better. I didn't like the previous update

FINAL UPDATE:



I decided to edit it, I wasn't completely cool with the animation, this is the result now:

 

The border does help.

But the brightness of the Person kinda makes the rest of the siggy look dull.

 

I could make the rest brighter too, and the elfish letters too

 

7/10 i like it with border

 

Change the font, make the light in the back lighter, but not too light.

 

hey damien, do you think you could make a banner thing for my website cuz i really need one and u look very good at making them ;p, if so please pm me.

 

6/10 Good job though.
Only problem is the background just looks dull compared to the person.

 

This is it!
'till now the best one IMO

 

Yea, very good, just don't black out the background completely. The font is much better.

 

I thought it wouldn't look good if the BG was too light.
And I just came up with a nice idea, an animation, and this is the result. It could be better, but I don't know if I wanna improve it.


Maybe I could use more frames, dunno

 

I liked the first font better tbh...lol.

 

looks good. 4/5

 

I live the third one!! a 10/10 for im!! w00t! =P

 

prepare to be blown away, the flame even moves now, and the animation is a bit smoother now

 

Woah, the flames are sweet, good job :]

 

ye, and it was quite easy, I just used "liquify" to change the flame

 

cant hardly read the text

 

Render is pretty slapped on, terrible text, cheesy effects, bad animation... Not too impressed.

The BS is too dul and plain, sure a moving flame is alright, border is behind her which looks terrible if you don't have the skill to make it look goodand any animation just ruins the sig. Really basic and hard on the eye.

 

it's my third photoshop sig ever, I hardly use that program, and the last one was made over a year ago, I'm not a pro or something

 

lmao like much editing ?