Ok this sig i made isnt my first but its a new style i learned... and when i mean new i dont mean its never been seen before but i mean to me its a new style im trying ^ well there it is :S
Not much to it... You've just selected random areas over layers and filtered them to buggery. Sorry, not great. 2/10
This sig isn't that bad and could have potential but you messed up on some things. The first thing is the renders, which is very blurry. Always try and get the best quality render. If you can't find a good quality render for the thing your looking for... simply don't use one. There render looks like you didn't resize it properly which probably gave it that bad quality look. When resizing an image, always hold shift and move the diagonal bars. Always try your best to blend the render into the background. Read some tutorials and you'll get better.
"Fair" is being truthful about your opinion on the quality of the signature, so therefore it is fair.