TDD vs. Durial Round 1 - Anime

Vote and post why, if you do not post why, your vote is excluded.

Round 1.

(Duri, you've won this round ¬.¬)

 

The top one is getting my vote. I know who made it, but it has no gain as to which I chose for. You used crowns in it, which is a soon-to-be pop-culture symbol. It's still up-and-coming, and it's good to be ahead of the curve, so I give it to you. The second one is also comparably uncomplicated.

 

wait, you're voting for that one on the sole reason it has crowns...?

the hell?

 

No. Lol. I'm voting for it because they are thinking ahead of the curve. Finding out the trends of tomorrow now. And all things considered, the second one looks like there was no more than a focus blur applied, with poor fonts.

 

Heh, you know it's a good thing when you/I can tell who made a sig by how the sig looks. #1 looks like a better version of number two. But the font in #2 is much better IMO.

My vote goes to number to #1.

 

The bottom has better lighting and text but I prefer the effects in the top one and I like the vibrant colors in it more.

 

I voted for the top one because I like that the objects have a more clearer definition compared to the second one that is mostly blurred. That's just the kind of thing I like. Also I like the text effect in the first one and I think it goes nicely with the sig

 

Bottom one is my vote.

 

The bottom one gets my vote, i honestly don't know who's is who's but i'm guessing it's Durials by the style.

Anyway, it's more neat and the top one is a little cluttered.

 

I voted the botom one, nice flow and lightning

 

first 1 ftw.

 

Second one, I like the blur effects. The second one has too many things in the background, I think the render looks good with a pretty simple background. Also, the first one has a little too many colors in my opinion. Good job, both of you, but I am going to have to go with Durial on this one.

 

First one, i like it most, its a bit messy near the head but it looks really neat, it has a pretty good flow

 

the bottom one is obviously durials work, it is well blended and the background fits well, thats why it gets my vote

 

I voted for the 1st one. I tend to like the brighter sigs, plus it seems to flow better to me than the 2nd one. Also it has some pretty good colors in it, plus it looks like he might of used some Vector brushes. Correct me if I'm wrong though.

 

I choose the second one.....As Xjaa said: It's blended into the backround. Thats why it also gets my vote.

 

TDD's has my vote, I really like the effects he used on that one, even though i don't like the crowns..

 

I'd have to say TDD's sig.

I like the way it flows and blends with the render and vice-versa.
The glow works well and the sig is nearly all perfectly placed.

Although, Durial's did come fair close

 

Devils Son

there is no render it's a stock making the placement the same thing >.<

see TDD told you you'd rape me =p.


Also I hate crowns tis not new tis VERY old.

 

Wasnt much of a fan of the first one, Kinda off if you ask me. The crowns was what made me wonder why and the randon clipping mask. The second one had more effect around the had instead of all over the place.